Better to Light a Candle: Chapter One—Prepping the Next Generation
Editor’s Note: This is the first in a series of columns on a new university course in PCB manufacturing at Michigan Technological University. Marc will chronicle the progress of this class, interview the guest lecturers, introduce the students, etc.
There has been a considerable amount of (electronic) ink and words shared in our industry bemoaning the graying-out of our industry and the growing shortage of skilled people at all levels. (See the May 2017 PCB007 Magazine column “Help Wanted—and How!” for just one example). As is usually the case, though, when all is said and done, more has been said than done.
That is why it was so refreshing to learn of someone who has decided to do something about it. Enter Dr. Christopher Middlebrook, a professor at Michigan Technological University (MTU) in Houghton, Michigan. On January 14, 2019, he will open the first session of “EE4800: Printed Circuit Board Fabrication”—a hands-on engineering class intended to give undergraduate students an introduction to the basics of printed circuit design, fabrication, and assembly. Here’s an abridged excerpt of the course description:
“Printed circuit board fabrication techniques are presented and explored utilizing wet-chemical process techniques. Single and multilayer boards using internal layers for power and ground planes as well as plated feed-through via structures, solder masks, and silk screens will be discussed. While hands-on fabrication will be the main focus, students will be introduced to software design packages specific to circuit layout and design. Final testing and evaluation of the fabricated boards will be performed.”
I have had the pleasure of working with Dr. Middlebrook along with a growing number of other well-seasoned PCB professionals who share a concern about our ability to sustain a viable printed circuit industry into the future here in North America. The equipment, materials, and processes available are very basic (and some show evidence of scrounging and “shoestring engineering”), but it all works. The class will allow each student to complete a multilayer PCB, using the same underlying processes used to build a conventional multilayer PCB in production from start to finish (Figure 1).
Figure 1: MTU’s equipment suite for their new course in PCB fabrication.
From one perspective, the students get a closer experience of the basic principles than they would be in a highly-automated or conveyorized operation. They will also gain some exposure to the more industrial and high-tech world due to the active involvement of nearby Calumet Electronics Corporation, with opportunities to see the larger-scale versions of the processes used in the class. The value of proximity to a highly supportive active printed circuit operation is a significant force multiplier in making this an effective experience for the students.
Much of the classroom input will come from guest lecturers (that same body of well-seasoned veterans) and companies volunteering their time and efforts. The common thread among them is that they can see the long-term benefits to the industry of this small initial effort, and can imagine others like it that may follow. Using this small class of 18 students as a starting point and demonstrating and debugging the concept, the prospect of expanding into more sophisticated design tools, advanced structures, and robust operations in future classes at MTU is realistic.
Dr. Christopher Middlebrook Interview
The following interview I did with Dr. Middlebrook may give you a little insight into the driver behind this effort.
Marc Carter: How did you start thinking about a class like this?
Dr. Chris Middlebrook: Feedback was received from the industry and DoD with regard to the lack of experience and exposure of prospective students in aspects of printed circuit design and fabrication, and I wanted to address this deficiency. In addition, as a result of a previous research product, we had pieces of the basic fabrication equipment available, and combining those with other older equipment from back in the day when we performed board manufacturing made it realizable. It also helps to have Calumet Electronics in our geographic location as a resource. One of MTU’s strengths is that we pride ourselves in being a technological university that educates and develops our student body to hit the ground running with hands-on experience when they start their careers, and printed circuits and electronics is a perfect match.
Carter: Was it hard to sell the value of this concept given that it has to compete for other MTU resources?
Middlebrook: Many areas in electrical engineering are hot and growing right now, and developing a new program that may compete for resources is certainly a challenge. MTU, being a relatively smaller university, allows itself to be more agile and attentive to industrial, DoD, and student needs. Connecting the areas—such as illustrating that cloud-based computing has to exist physically somewhere where hardware is utilized—shows the integration of a multidisciplinary approach to education. When I poll students, they are always excited about learning printed circuit fabrication and obtaining hands-on experience to understand the complete design, fabrication, testing, and implementation process. Having outside input from places such as Calumet Electronics, Plexus, and Gentex that hire our students has been critical.
Carter: Have you been surprised by the industry response?
Middlebrook: Beginning this program implementation, I knew we had the support of Calumet Electronics and other experts such as yourself, but I am continually amazed by the response and guidance from industry. We have been in discussions with several industry experts who have expressed great interest in not only advising on our specific fabrication processes but also contributing to guest lectures and seminars. Having this talent directly interact with students brings a larger global perspective to a typical university offered course.
Carter: What would help you make this course as effective as possible in this first iteration? What do you need right now?
Middlebrook: Continued guidance in the shaping of the course and soon-to-be-developed courses from subject matter experts is critical to ensure our students gain the necessary skills that employers are looking to fill. While we have some of the basic equipment in place to launch the course, we are always looking for companies and organizations that might be willing to donate or loan used equipment that is being replaced, underutilized, or upgraded. We strive to develop and align the program to the state-of-the-art techniques and equipment. From a student perspective, they may not necessarily have to have the latest and greatest equipment to understand basic printed circuit fabrication techniques.
Calumet Electronics Interview
The eager, voluntary support from the industry has been tremendous. It’s not just individual graybeards that have stepped up, either. Earlier in the article, Calumet Electronics support was noted. I asked Dr. Meredith LaBeau, Calumet’s chief engineer, about their serious support in helping this class get off the ground.
Carter: Thanks for taking the time for a few questions, Dr. LaBeau.
Dr. Meredith LaBeau: Thanks for having me comment on this unique program in our backyard at a strong, regional university where we draw many new, young, vibrant, and talented employees to Calumet Electronics.
Carter: How did Calumet Electronics get involved in this effort?
LaBeau: In 2008, Calumet Electronics engaged in a Naval Air Systems Command (NAVAIR) research program HIOPTIMA project that then transformed into a Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) project with MTU. Although this project was not funded into a secondary stage, this set the stage for our continuing partnership with MTU and Dr. Middlebrook. Fast forward many years to this past spring when Dr. Middlebrook contacted Calumet about developing a joint internship program that would assist in developing the practical lab for this course, using tabletop equipment from the SIBR project. We readily joined forces to support our partner and ensure the continuing education and development of engineers in what some consider a dying industry. Calumet is actively engaged in activities to support the domestic supply chain to be robust and resilient especially for customers such as the DoD. Calumet has been supporting an intern since May 2018 to assist in the development of this course.
Carter: This has to be diverting some key resources that Calumet could use for other, more immediate needs. What’s in it for Calumet Electronics?
LaBeau: Calumet Electronics strives to continue to ensure a thriving domestic supply chain, which includes knowledgeable engineering staff from designers to process engineers. Developing a close partnership with MTU allows Calumet to recruit some of the best and brightest locally who will soon have visibility to a vital industry for the United States—an industry that we all depend on for the future of technology. Educating these engineers through this class and other potential classes at MTU will provide the required next generation of designers, problem solvers, and leaders.
Carter: What would you like to say to your colleagues in the industry—including your competitors—about getting involved in this effort or helping one like it get started?
LaBeau: It is vital that all actors in the PCB industry support a robust domestic supply chain. Building a strong relationship with local universities provides educated talent, partners in future years, and a career ladder for the aging workforce to successfully transfer their knowledge to continue innovation and support our nation.
For further information, email Dr. Middlebrook (firstname.lastname@example.org) or myself (email@example.com).
Marc Carter has worked in the electronics interconnection industry since 1984 in a variety of roles in fabrication and assembly materials, processes, environmental compliance, and supply chain management activities around the world. He has had the honor and privilege of working with and learning from many of the true giants of this industry in multiple functions over many years. His experience includes a major mil-aero OEM, field and development work at materials suppliers to the printed circuit industry, and an educational stint as the sole proprietor of a manufacturer’s agency representing multiple high-tech mil-aero material suppliers.