TTM: Consult Fabricators Early for PCB Designs

Reading time ( words)

julie_ellis.jpgShaughnessy: It looks like something that would make a fabricator say, "Are you serious?" 

Ellis: The industry has changed tremendously since I started in it, that's for sure. I used to wire wrap assemblies when I was a kid.

Shaughnessy: In your talk, you mentioned how everyone talks about drilling vias below six mils. But then you point out that six mils is only two times the width of a human hair. 

Ellis: Yes. I feel like I’m always splitting hairs when I build fine-pitch stack-ups, because they require trade-off analysis between minimum aspect ratio, hole sizes, pad and antipad sizes, the space left between those pads, and how many traces can be run between the pads, if any. 6 mils is the smallest mechanical drill size we’ll use in North America, and it’s only the diameter of 2 human hairs and smaller than a hypodermic needle. Because 6 mil drill bits break easily, can’t be re-sharpened, and are very expensive, Asia sites rarely use them. So I never design a stack-up for our China sites using a 6 mil drill. But as hole size increases, so do the pad diameters in order to maintain annular ring requirements, and that can kill the routing space between pads.

Come to think of it, another thing I would like to see engineers do more often is consider the production site technical capabilities. Offshore PCBs are significantly lower in cost, because they’re optimized for continuous processes that don’t need to be interrupted or require highly advanced, but slow, equipment or processes. Asia sites have excellent capabilities, but they are not all at extreme tech levels of some of our N. America sites. So designs should be done in accordance with production site guidelines and available materials. 

Shaughnessy: Sure. Well, it was a great talk. You covered a lot of really cool cutting-edge stuff. The designers in the crowd really enjoyed it.

Ellis: Thank you.

Shaughnessy: Thank you, Julie. I appreciate your time.



Suggested Items

Words of Advice: Drawbacks to Your PCB Data Format?

08/15/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
In a recent survey, we asked the following question: What is the biggest drawback to your current PCB data format? Here are a few of the answers, edited slightly for clarity.

IPC Reliability Forum Wrap-up With Brook Sandy-Smith

08/12/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
I attended the recent IPC High-Reliability Forum and Microvia Summit in Baltimore, Maryland. The speakers and panelists focused on a variety of topics, but one issue that kept popping up was the failure of some microvias on military and aerospace PCBs. Fortunately, some smart technologists are focusing on determining the cause of these via failures. I asked Brook Sandy-Smith, IPC’s technical education program manager, to give us a quick wrap-up of this event.

Denny Fritz: The Difference Between Quality and Reliability

08/06/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
I recently spoke with industry veteran (and I-Connect007 columnist) Denny Fritz about the relationship between quality and reliability—two terms that are unequal but often used interchangeably. We also discuss the current state of lead-free solders in the U.S. military and defense market as well as the microvia reliability issues Denny focused on at IPC’s High-Reliability Forum and Microvia Summit in Baltimore, Maryland.

Copyright © 2019 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.