The Bare (Board) Truth: Fabrication Starts With Solid Design Practices

Reading time ( words)

“All right! Don’t rush me. I’m a-thinking…and my head hurts.” —Yosemite Sam

It’s a fact: Great board design is the key to a great PCB. I’m even more certain of this after spending two days in a wonderful class presented by Rick Hartley titled “Control of Noise, EMI, and Signal Integrity in High-speed Circuits and PCBs.”

First, I would like to thank Rick for teaching his course. I thought I had a pretty decent grasp of controlled impedance and signal integrity, but the gaps in my knowledge base can fill the Grand Canyon. This class helped me see how important the design truly is not only for functionality but also for minimizing revisions and passing EMI testing the first time. I deal with incoming designs for a living, but I had no idea how many things you should consider when doing a board layout, from part placement and organization to via location.

I guess I am just accustomed to simply using my field solver and answering fabrication-related questions to make a PCB producible. I thought I knew it all, from effective Dk and Er to layer “nesting” based on the layer interfaces and prepreg selection for various controlled impedance structures. I assumed I knew what I needed to know from how the color and dielectric of a mask can affect controlled impedances to the use of ultra-thin dielectrics to increase inductance to pass EMI. Well, I was wrong!

How far we have come from the days of slower-speed designs; their edge rates didn’t matter very much because they were are basically lumped elements. Those old designs are nothing like today’s high-speed designs and all the bugaboos associated with distributed length line designs. Understanding the impact of nearby traces on controlled impedance lines and how magnetic fields work can make the difference between a successful design and a quagmire of self-created issues, such as common-mode emissions that can make or break passing EMI testing.

I even learned a few things about via filling with silver-epoxy or copper-epoxy for thermal applications. Remember, if you are using a via fill for conductivity, you are missing the point; the electromagnetic fields are generated around the barrel of the holes, not the material filling the hole. In some cases during Rick’s presentation, I wanted to slap myself in the forehead and say, “I should have had a V-8!”

Rick showed one slide with four examples to be rated from least to most of radiated EMI. Fortunately, they are the same as a firing order in most four-cylinder combustion engines (1, 3, 4, 2) and pretty much everyone understood not to rout a trace over a split or a slot.

On many occasions during Rick’s presentation, I began to make sense of some of the crazy things we have been asked as a fabricator over the years. Eight years ago, one customer asked us to mill a channel in a thick PCB using an end mill to make the corners as square as possible (not routed with a radii) and plate the trough and cap the whole structure with what appeared to be a wide plated “trace” running the entire length and width of the channel. At either end was a small hole where I was told they would inject a liquid. Then, I saw Rick’s slide saying, “Apply a wave whose half wavelength is equal to distance X. We have a perfect balance and a true waveguide.”

To read this entire column, which appeared in the June 2019 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.



Suggested Items

Flex Standards Update With Nick Koop

11/14/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
This month, I interviewed Nick Koop—director of flex technology at TTM Technologies, a veteran “flex guy” and instructor, and a leader of several IPC flex standards committees. Nick provides an update for the committees he’s involved with and discusses some of the challenges that he sees as more designers enter the world of flex.

Why Does the PCB Industry Still Use Gerber?

11/07/2019 | Karel Tavernier, Ucamco
Every so often, I hear technologists ask why so many PCB designers still use Gerber. That is a fair question. Ucamco has over 35 years of experience in developing and supporting cutting-edge software and hardware solutions for the global PCB industry. Our customers—small, medium, and large PCB fabricators—include the electronics industry’s leading companies, and many of them have been with us for over 30 years. We are dedicated to our industry and excellence in everything we do, which includes our custodianship of the Gerber format.

Communication, Part 5: Internet Impedance Calculators for Modeling

11/05/2019 | Steve Williams, The Right Approach Consulting LLC
Bob Chandler of CA Design and Mark Thompson of Prototron Circuits address how new engineers use internet impedance calculators for modeling (e.g., formulas versus recipes) in Part 5 of this series. Do you use impedance calculators that you found on the internet? Read on!

Copyright © 2019 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.