The Shaughnessy Report: Everything Starts with the Designer

Reading time ( words)

Once upon a time in the not-too-distant past, PCB designers were the Rodney Dangerfields of the electronics industry. They didn’t get no respect, and in some cases, not much of a salary either. But times have changed. Now, many designers are starting to realize the power they wield over the whole electronics process.

The folks downstream in fabrication and assembly understood this sentiment long ago, usually expressing it as “It’s the designer’s fault.” But recently, a variety of manufacturers have told me, “Everything starts with design.”

That’s certainly a more positive spin! Everything does start with design—the positive outcomes as well as the negative. The designer can control much of the development of the PCB, and often the final product, with a little planning during the earliest part of the design cycle. It’s a designer’s responsibility to do everything possible to avoid getting that call from the CAM department at 5:30 pm on a Friday.

We surveyed our designer readers in preparation for this issue. Here’s one of the more pertinent questions: What steps do you take to make the job easier for your fabrication and assembly providers? Here are a few of the replies:

  • Communicate directly with them, especially if you want to try something new.
  • Follow proven design methodologies and rules.
  • Get feedback on previous builds to improve upcoming projects.
  • Try to insist that the fab house runs Valor DFM.
  • Minimize layer count.
  • Use the largest trace widths, via sizes, and clearances we can.
  • Don’t use more demanding fab technology than absolutely necessary.
  • Plan your stack-up with your fabricator.
  • Reduce the drill count.
  • Follow IPC standards.

A lot of the replies were variations on these themes: Communicate. Don’t throw your downstream partners any technological curve balls. Go big if at all possible, except for layer count. Follow the IPC guidelines.

All of this might make us think that the days of throwing the design “over the wall” are just about over. But there are still flies in the proverbial oatmeal. We know that communication is still a big problem; many designers never speak to their fabricator until they get that Friday evening phone call. But many designers say that they have no earthly idea where their boards are going to be manufactured. They just design each board so that it can, hopefully, be fabricated anywhere.

To read this entire column, which appeared in the June 2019 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.



Suggested Items

Max Seeley: Some Designers Hesitant to Adopt New Tech

02/20/2020 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
I spoke with Max Seeley of 3M about a design class he presented at AltiumLive in Frankfurt, Germany. We also discussed autorouting and the continuing advances in EDA tools, as well as the schism between users who embrace new technology and those who still prefer to layout their boards the old-fashioned way. Which camp do you belong to?

Joe Clark Says DownStream Is Ready for More Growth in 2020

02/20/2020 | Kelly Dack, CID+, EPTAC
Joe Clark, co-founder of DownStream Technologies, gives Kelly Dack an overview of the company and their innovative product line, which serves to smooth the bumps that can occur between source design output and manufacturing line input. As Joe explains, 2019 was a great year for the company, and he expects that trend to hold through 2020.

IPC Designers Council Has a New Name: IPC Design

02/11/2020 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
Yes, you read that right. The IPC Designers Council is now known as IPC Design. Many of you have heard secondhand stories about what this change will entail, so I asked IPC to shed some light on this subject. I recently spoke with IPC’s Teresa Rowe and Patrick Crawford about what’s changing, what’s not, and IPC’s plans to provide improved infrastructure for PCB design content and curriculum.

Copyright © 2020 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.