Elementary, Mr. Watson: The Four Horsemen of Copper Confusion
The Shaughnessy Report: Zee Plane! Zee Plane!
Target Condition: Distribution of Power—Denounce the Ounce
Cannonball Stack for Conductor Roughness Modeling
June 24, 2015 | Bert Simonovich, Lamsim EnterprisesEstimated reading time: 2 minutes
In the GB/s regime, accurate modeling of conductor losses is a precursor to successful high-speed serial link designs. Failure to model roughness effects can ruin your day. For example, Figure 1 shows the simulated total loss of a 40-inch PCB trace without roughness compared to measured data. Total loss is the sum of dielectric and conductor losses. As can be seen, with just -3dB delta in insertion loss between simulated and measured data at 12.5 GHz, there is half the eye height opening with rough copper at 25GB/s.
According to Wikipedia, close-packing of equal spheres is defined as “a dense arrangement of congruent spheres in an infinite, regular arrangement (or lattice)." The cubic close-packed and hexagonal close-packed are examples of two regular lattices. The cannonball stack is an example of a cubic close-packing of equal spheres, and is the basis of modeling the surface roughness of a conductor in this article.
So, what do cannonballs have to do with modeling copper roughness anyway? Well, other than sharing the principle of close packing of equal spheres, and having a cool name, not very much.
Background
In PCB construction, there is no such thing as a perfectly smooth conductor surface. There is always some degree of roughness that promotes adhesion to the dielectric material. Unfortunately this roughness also contributes to additional conductor loss.
Electro-deposited (ED) copper is widely used in the PCB industry. The manufacturing process sees a large rotating drum, made of polished stainless steel or titanium, which is partially submerged in a bath of copper sulfate solution. The cathode terminal is attached to the drum, while the anode terminal is submerged in the solution. A DC voltage supplies the anode and cathode with the correct polarity.
As the drum slowly rotates, copper is deposited onto it. A finished sheet of ED copper foil has two sides. The matte side faces the copper sulfate bath, while the drum side faces the rotating drum. Consequently, the drum side is always smoother than the matte side.
The matte side is usually attached to the prepreg sheets, prior to final pressing and curing, to form the core laminate. Prepreg is the term commonly used for a weave of glass fiber yarns pre-impregnated with resin which is only partially cured. To enhance adhesion, the matte side has additional treatment applied to roughen the surface. For high frequency boards, sometimes the drum side of the foil is laminated to the core. In this case it is referred to as reversed treated (RT) foil. Even after treatment, it is still smoother than standard treated foils.
To read this article, which appeared in the May 2015 issue of The PCB Design Magazine, click here.
Share on:
Testimonial
"The I-Connect007 team is outstanding—kind, responsive, and a true marketing partner. Their design team created fresh, eye-catching ads, and their editorial support polished our content to let our brand shine. Thank you all! "
Sweeney Ng - CEE PCBSuggested Items
The Impact of the AI Boom on PCB and Raw Materials Supply Chains
11/13/2025 | Mark Goodwin, Ventec International GroupThe PCB industry is entering a period of unprecedented structural change, driven by the demands of artificial intelligence and advanced computing. What was once a cyclical market has become a capacity race. It’s one that rewards foresight, collaboration, and strategic supply partnerships. Understanding these dynamics is essential for maintaining stability and growth across all market segments. This report, created by Ventec International Group, provides a clear view of how AI-driven demand is reshaping the PCB materials landscape and what actions are required to secure long-term supply.
Elementary, Mr. Watson: The Four Horsemen of Copper Confusion
11/12/2025 | John Watson -- Column: Elementary, Mr. WatsonIf there were a PCB Design Dictionary of Confusing Terms, the cover would feature four words that have baffled generations of engineers: polygons, pours, planes, and floods—or what I refer to as the four horsemen of copper confusion. They sound simple, as if they belong in a geometry textbook or a weather report, but in PCB design, they overlap, develop, and sound interchangeable until you realize they aren't.
Alpha Insights, Performance by Design: Understanding Heat at the Core of Every Design
11/11/2025 | Team Alpha -- Column: Alpha Insights: Performance by DesignPower isn’t just about current. It’s about control. As electronic systems grow smaller and faster, every amp and every layer generates a new source of heat. That heat is more than a byproduct. It’s a measure of efficiency, a benchmark of performance, and often the first indication of failure.
The Shaughnessy Report: Zee Plane! Zee Plane!
11/11/2025 | Andy Shaughnessy -- Column: The Shaughnessy ReportPlanes aren’t magic, but they are big time-savers. Without planes, designers would have to create thousands of traces to accomplish the same objectives. You can imagine the first time a designer thought about using a sheet of copper, asking, “Hey, why am I killing myself laying out all these traces? Can’t I just use this sheet of copper instead?”
November 2025 Design007 Magazine: Proper Plane Design
11/10/2025 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamWithout planes, designers would have to create thousands of traces to accomplish the same objectives. Power planes provide low impedance and stable power to every component on the board, much like a large power bus. Ground planes stabilize reference voltage, improve thermal performance, and help preclude EMI issues. Power and ground plane design is often a battle of tradeoffs.