Acceptance Testing Of Low-Ag Reflow Solder Alloys (Part 2)

Reading time ( words)

In Part 2 of this two-part article series, the authors discussed the test results for low-silver alloys using these solder paste alloy assessment protocols for BGAs and leaded components, and the impact of the alloys on printed circuit assembly process windows.

Test Results and Discussion

Manufacturing DoE Results

IMC Thickness

Measured on BGA Manufacturing DoE Test Boards (see Figure 1 in Part 1) that were reflowed 3 times with a peak reflow temperature of 250 °C and 120 seconds TAL.

Two BGA body sizes were evaluated [14 mm and 23 mm]. IMC thicknesses for alloys A and B were normally distributed with no significant difference between the large and small BGA. For alloys C and D, greater variability in the large BGA IMC thickness resulted in values significantly different than smaller BGA (as seen in Figure 1 and Table 1).


Figure 1: IMC thickness distribution by Alloy (A-D) and BGA size (large/small)

Table 1: Summary of IMC thicknesses (microns)


Copper Dissolution

This was measured on the BGA Manufacturing DoE Test Boards (see Figure 1 in Part 1) that were reflowed 3 times with a peak reflow temperature of 250°C and 120 seconds TAL.

Cu thickness measurements were made at each solder joint, in the middle of the joint and underneath the soldermask adjacent to the joint. Cu removed was the difference in copper thickness at these two locations. Cu dissolved was determined by subtracting Epsilon (thickness of Cu removed during soldermask etch in the PCB fab process) from the Cu removed values.


Figure 2: Cu dissolution distribution by alloy

Table 2: Summary of Cu dissolved (microns)


The amount of Cu dissolved after soldering was less for the low silver alloys than that for SAC305. The Cu dissolution results were normally distributed for the evaluated alloys but varied with alloy and BGA size (as seen in Figure 2 and Table 2). The Cu dissolution performance varied by BGA size, though not in a consistent fashion. While alloy B showed comparable Cu dissolved values between the 2 BGA sizes, alloy C and D both had more Cu dissolved for the larger BGA while alloy A had greater Cu dissolution values for the small BGA (this could be attributable to bare board Cu characteristics between the different vendors).



Suggested Items

90% Solder Dross Recovery: Eliminate Waste, Save Money

10/20/2020 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007
The impact of 90% solder dross recovery can have a substantial impact on reducing waste and increasing cost savings. Nolan Johnson recently spoke with Jay Hardin, MS2® product manager at P. Kay Metal, about the process and benefits of efficient solder dross recovery, as well as product roadmaps, the soldering machine market, and raw materials supply chain for solder alloy manufacturing. As Jay says, “For many companies, the savings are in the thousands or millions” of dollars.

Just Ask Paul: Automotive and Lead-Free Solders

10/14/2020 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
We asked you to send in your questions for Happy Holden, Joe Fjelstad, Eric Camden, John Mitchell, and Greg Smith in our “Just Ask” series. Now, MacDermid Alpha Electronics Solutions’ Paul Salerno gets a chance to answer a question. Paul Salerno is a global portfolio manager for SMT applications focused on the automotive and consumer market segments. He holds a bachelor’s degree in materials engineering as well as an MBA in finance and marketing from Rutgers University.

Real Time with… SMTAI 2020: Reflections on the Technical Conference

10/07/2020 | Real Time with...SMTAI
This year’s SMTA International Conference and Exposition went virtual! Pete Starkey explains how the SMTA team did a fine job in difficult circumstances to present an interactive show and technical conference. Here, he highlights four of the papers that particularly caught his interest.

Copyright © 2020 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.