Rice Research: AI Technology No Silver Bullet for Hiring the Best Employees
November 22, 2021 | Rice UniversityEstimated reading time: 1 minute
Artificial intelligence technology is now used by a growing number of companies looking to hire the best employees, but new research from Rice University warns how it can incorporate biases and overlook important characteristics among job applicants.
"To use games as an example, remember how kids avoid tests and love games?" Oswald says. "The same idea applies when hiring, where the hope is that applicants will be attracted to playing a game, and the game data will be at least as effective as a traditional employment test. No doubt games are engaging, but we need much more data to argue for the effectiveness of games as selection tools in hiring situations."
Using machine learning in the hiring process also raises concerns about accessibility and diversity.
"Take an example where job applicants go through a video interview, and their data are then scored by a machine learning algorithm," Oswald says. "It might pick up on job-relevant features such as responses concerning job knowledge or conscientiousness. But we are now highly aware that machine learning algorithms may also pick up on many incidental features irrelevant to the job, such as tone of voice, gestures and facial expressions."
Oswald points out that if an applicant is in a minority group or has a disability, the algorithms might not have as much data on these groups to understand and judge their unique talents, which could then limit diversity in the hiring process.
Finally, this research expresses serious ethical concerns about employers reviewing information that was not part of the employee's application package. In the past, job applicants could more carefully manage the materials reviewed by a potential employer, but now, machine technology can mine the internet for unrelated materials.
“Just because organizations can mine the internet for applicant information doesn’t mean that they should," Oswald says. "And related to this concern, we are now seeing how issues of applicant privacy and fairness are beginning to influence organizational policies as well as state and federal laws."
Oswald and his fellow authors hope the research will serve as a call to action for those building and using this technology to engage researchers to evaluate liabilities, risks and other associated problems.
Suggested Items
Nolan’s Notes: Coming to Terms With AI
05/07/2024 | Nolan Johnson -- Column: Nolan's NotesHow fast do things move in the world of data analytics? Here’s an example. We’ve been planning this issue on artificial intelligence for the past few months, and, in fact, I had already written this column about a month ago. Then I went to IPC APEX EXPO and upended it all. I originally had compared AI to drag racing in that (CPU) horsepower and new (data) vehicles have steadily delivered higher performance competition. That seemed pretty accurate given how generative AI models dominated the popular media with amazing results—and sometimes spectacular crashes.
RTX's Advanced Ground System for Space-based Missile Warning Now Operational
05/06/2024 | RTXAn advanced ground system for space-based missile warning developed by Raytheon, an RTX business, is now operational at the U.S. Space Force's Overhead Persistent Infrared Battlespace Awareness Center (OBAC).
Cigent, Swissbit Announce Partnership to Enhance Endpoint Data Security
05/06/2024 | CigentCigent, a leading provider of endpoint data protection solutions, and Swissbit, a leading manufacturer of storage, security, and embedded IoT solutions, today announced a strategic partnership to offer a comprehensive portfolio of secure storage drives designed to safeguard endpoint data against a growing landscape of cyberthreats.
Industrial PC Market Size to Record $1.75 Billion Growth from 2023-2027
05/03/2024 | PRNewswireThe global industrial pc market size is estimated to grow by USD 1.75 billion from 2023 to 2027, according to Technavio. This growth is expected to occur at a Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of almost 6.29% during the forecast period.
Gartner Survey: 61% of Organizations Evolving D&A Model Due to AI
05/01/2024 | Gartner, Inc.Sixty-one percent of organizations are forced to evolve or rethink their data and analytics (D&A) operating model because of the impact of disruptive artificial intelligence (AI) technologies, according to a new Gartner, Inc. survey.