Rigid-flex Stackup: It’s a 3D World
September 20, 2023 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

Z-zero founder Bill Hargin has been studying stackup design techniques for years. He developed the company’s PCB stackup planning software, and he wrote The Printed Circuit Designer’s Guide to… Stackups: The Design within the Design.
In this interview, Bill shares his thoughts on designing rigid-flex stackups, the challenges they bring, and what rigid board designers need to know about designing stackups in 3D. “Flexperts” Mark Finstad of Flexible Circuit Technologies and Nick Koop of TTM Technologies also offer insight into the many tradeoffs that rigid-flex designers face.
You literally “wrote the book” on stackup design techniques. What are some of the unique challenges designers face with rigid-flex stackups?
As I often say, the mechanical world and the electrical world are at odds with each other. We wouldn’t need to concern ourselves with signal integrity if the physical/mechanical worlds weren’t involved.
The rigid-flex structure carries a lot of advantages—reliability, dynamic flexure, and the ability to get things done in tight spaces. But there’s the additional burden of needing to manage a mechanical world that has additional dimensions or “degrees of freedom.” A rigid stackup, for example, can easily be viewed in 2D, and that world is relatively easy for most electrical hardware engineers to understand and manage. You have impedance, frequency, and loss and then physical and electrical parameters that drive them. When flex substacks come into the picture, the fact that the flex portion needs to bend turns it into a 3D mechanical engineering problem that takes some time to learn. This is where you really need to lean on a flex fabricator’s expertise. Toward that end, I decided to poll a few “flexperts,” including Mark Finstad from Flexible Circuit Technologies and Nick Koop from TTM. Now I’ll weave their thoughts in with some of my own.
Mark emphasized that rigid-flex stackups have to blend both rigid and flexible base materials into the final product, and that these materials all stretch and shrink at different rates due to processes like etching and lamination. Additionally, flex materials can stretch and shrink just due to temperature and humidity changes. To further complicate things, these materials typically don’t move at the same rate in the X and Y axes. Most manufacturers have a good history with many materials, so they know how much to scale their artwork and programs to account for these dimensional instabilities. Also, laser direct imaging and smart laser and mechanical drills help with a lot of these issues, but the need to use those processing tools does come at a cost.
What do rigid board PCB designers need to understand about rigid-flex design and stackups?
Hargin: I don’t know if this will catch on, but I’ve started referring to rigid-flex design as “designing in 3D” or “3D design.” I doubt that someone who’s been designing rigid-flex boards (in 3D) for 20 years would learn much from my brief commentary here, so I’ll throw out a challenge to the rest of the designers who may benefit from this.
Along with HDI, rigid-flex PCBs have been trending up in recent years. Younger engineers would do well to start adding rigid-flex design skills to their repertoire in order to open up career opportunities. Maybe start with the rigid-flex chapter in my book on stackups and branch out from there. For signal integrity and EMI control, we like to have nearby reference planes for the current return path. But that additional
plane layer reduces the bend radius, so there are lots of new tradeoffs to make when you’re designing for flexibility.
There are some important differences relative to rigid PCBs that you should consider when designing a rigid-flex project. You can connect flex cores using a loose-leaf or bonded approach (Figure 1).
Click here to continue reading this interview which appears in the September 2023 issue of Design007 Magazine.
Suggested Items
Growth and Innovation at FCT
02/26/2025 | Marcy LaRont, I-Connect007During DesignCon, I met with Tony Plemel, senior applications engineer at Flexible Circuit Technologies (FCT), to discusses the company’s growth and expansion opportunities, including its expansion of its inTFlex EMS facility. In this interview, Tony explains how FCT’s commitment to customer service and focus on communication and responsiveness allow the company to leverage its capabilities for continued expansion.
Expansion, Retirement, and New Leadership at FCT
01/09/2025 | Marcy LaRont, PCB007 MagazineIn the dynamic landscape of interconnect solutions, Flexible Circuit Technology (FCT) is making waves through significant leadership changes and expansion initiatives. Vice President Carey Burkett, newly appointed executive vice president Ray Cottrell, and marketing director Abby Meyer share their vision for steering the company toward innovative growth. FCT has a robust focus on diverse markets such as medical, automotive, consumer electronics, and HDI (high density interconnect). They are accelerating FCT’s mission to provide exceptional value and service to customers throughout the product lifecycle.
IPC Releases Latest List of Standards and Revisions
12/17/2024 | IPC Community Editorial TeamEach quarter, IPC releases a list of standards that are new or have been updated. To view a complete list of newly published standards and standards revisions, translations, proposed standards for ballot, final drafts for industry review, working drafts, and project approvals, visit ipc.org/status. These are the latest releases for Q4 2024.
Flex PCB Design Best Practices with Dave Lackey
12/04/2024 | Brittany Martin, I-Connect007David Lackey, a flex circuit expert at American Standard Circuits, speaks about the advantages and challenges of designing with flexible and rigid-flex PCBs. He also discusses how consulting before the design phase can save time and costs by avoiding manufacturing issues and highlights the reliability and packaging benefits of flex technology, especially for compact designs in sectors like aerospace.
Global PCB Connections: A Technical Overview of Long-flex Printed Circuit Boards
11/14/2024 | Jerome Larez -- Column: Global PCB ConnectionsFlex printed circuit boards are an essential advancement in the electronics industry, enabling the development of flexible, lightweight, and durable electronic designs. As technology has evolved, long-flex PCBs have emerged as a key component in applications requiring extended or intricate routing paths. Because of their use in automotive, commercial, and medical devices, designers are becoming more comfortable designing PCBs with this technology. This column will explore their attributes and role in modern products. I will also offer some essential tips for designing with manufacturability in mind.