Underconstraining Your Materials? Leave It to the Experts
May 30, 2024 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamEstimated reading time: 1 minute
![](https://iconnect007.com/application/files/8716/9087/1242/Filbert_Arzola_250.jpg)
With traditional laminates now sporting improved resin systems, some OEMs are choosing various flavors of FR-4 instead of high-speed laminates for their high-speed designs—even RF applications. Avoiding overconstraining your materials in high-speed products can lead to considerable cost savings, not to mention a more streamlined trip through fabrication.
But what do designers and design engineers need to know before they start using traditional PCB laminates for RF applications? Raytheon’s Filbert Arzola is a principal electrical engineer, IPC instructor, and a big advocate of setting constraints correctly early in the design cycle. We caught up with him at IPC APEX EXPO when his Professional Development Course on constraints was taking a lunch break.
Andy Shaughnessy: It seemed fitting to talk with you here in Anaheim during your class on constraining your high-speed board correctly. Tell us a little about the class.
Filbert Arzola: Sure. One of the things we've learned is that some high-speed designers have, in the past, put too much focus on materials that had a certain glass weave. We went through so much waste trying to use glass weave at a certain angle. We had so much trouble getting a board done that we've gone to other material types, adding dielectric to them just to make things work better. I learned there are certain kinds of material and FR-4 materials, including one that, even though it's not the best, still gives a good end-product. The end product is what matters.
Kelly Dack: There's no question that consistency in materials, manufacturing, and performance is key. What are the elements of consistency in your opinion?
Arzola: You need to even be able to get the materials, and not just on time. Let's say you call a vendor and say, “I'm going to build these boards six months from now; can you make sure the material is there?” They'll say, “Sure, material availability is okay.” Then they go out and buy the material. But now, six months later, the material may be outdated with respect to the requirements we want to meet, and we can't use that material. So, that's a big deal.
To read this entire conversation, which appeared in the May 2024 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.
Suggested Items
Logitech Announces Future Positive Technology Challenge Winners
08/27/2024 | BUSINESS WIRELogitech International announced the winners of the annual Future Positive Challenge, a technology challenge designed to identify disruptive sustainable solutions in electronics. Six companies from around the globe were selected for their trailblazing solutions across printed circuit boards (PCB), batteries, materials, packaging, integrated circuits, and business models.
nano3Dprint Unveils Cutting-Edge Conductive Silver Ink Products in Collaboration with Creative Materials
08/27/2024 | PRWEBnano3Dprint, a leading additive manufacturing and printed electronics solutions provider, is thrilled to announce the launch of its groundbreaking Conductive Silver Ink Products for use in nano3Dprint's A2200, B3300 and MatDep Pro 3D printers.
The Pulse: Commonsense Cost Cutting
08/29/2024 | Martyn Gaudion -- Column: The PulseOne difference between engineering and pure science is that engineers (in most situations) are looking for cost-effectiveness. They do so by designing the most appropriate level of technology to maximize profitability with acceptable levels of application functionality. One area that is often overlooked is the energy cost of PCB production. At a recent EIPC conference, Dr. Maarten Cauwe of IMEC in Belgium presented a combined study of the lifecycle impact (LCI) of electronics systems and subassemblies. The study looked at the supply chain as well as the energy impact of HDIs.
Asymmetric Hybrid Printed Circuit Board Design: Warpage Considerations
08/27/2024 | Kaspar Tsang, Gause Hu, Jimmy Hsu, Aje Chang, Alan Sun, Brian Ho, Ryan Chang, and Thonas SuThe printed circuit board (PCB) accounts for a significant portion of the PCBA’s (printed circuit board assembly) BOM (bill of material) cost. Designs with hybrid PCB stackup are adopted to reduce the cost of the PCB by using less expensive laminate materials in layers that do not have routings for high-speed signals (e.g., power and ground layers). The conventional hybrid PCB stackup design is symmetrical in the middle. This engineering technique has been employed in the data center industry for quite some time. To extend the idea and optimize the purpose of hybrid PCB stackup design, the feasibility of an asymmetric hybrid stackup is currently being studied.
Elementary, Mr. Watson: Debunking Misconceptions in PCB Design
08/22/2024 | John Watson -- Column: Elementary, Mr. WatsonPCB design can be likened to the poem, “The Blind Man and the Elephant” by John Godfrey Saxe. In the poem, six blind men of Indostan “to learning much inclined,” went to see the elephant “that each by observation, might satisfy the mind.” The first man fell against the elephant and concluded it was like touching a wall. The second man felt the elephant’s tusk and exclaimed, "It is very like a spear." The third blind man, feeling the vast and squirming trunk, decided it was a snake. The fourth man felt the elephant's leg and said the elephant “is very like a tree." The fifth man touched the massive ears and decided an elephant is very like a fan. Finally, the sixth blind man, feeling the elephant’s swinging tail, proudly proclaimed, "I see, the elephant is very like a rope."