Counterfeit Concerns: Navigating the Risks
October 23, 2024 | Nolan Johnson, SMT007 MagazineEstimated reading time: 2 minutes
Nolan Johnson meets with Diganta Das, PhD, and Michael Azarian, PhD, research scientists at the CALCE Electronic Products and Systems Center at the University of Maryland, to discuss the increasing issue of counterfeiting in the electronics and assembly industry. Diganta and Michael highlight the need for robust detection methods and standards to mitigate risks, specifically referencing SAE AS6171 for inspection and AS5553 for counterfeit mitigation. They cover real-world cases, like counterfeit network equipment scandals to relatively simple issues of consumer electronics accessories to illustrate the complexity of the issue and debate the philosophical implications of labeling products that contain a few minor counterfeit components as “counterfeit.”
To address the problem, they suggest that standards organizations like SAE and IPC could play a crucial role. The conversation closes with a call to action for EMS companies to actively participate in creating, shaping, and adhering to these standards to protect themselves and their customers.
Nolan Johnson: Counterfeiting of subassemblies seems to be something we didn’t need to think about previously. What do you see?
Diganta Das: Counterfeiters are getting much more confident about putting together a whole infrastructure, not just for an individual consumer but even commercial B2B purchasers and others. One relatively recent case involved a company and its owner found guilty and sentenced for criminal acts in the state of New Jersey. In this case, the owner put together a system infrastructure of gathering and refurbishing old network control equipment, adding software that would beat the detection software, packaging it in authentic-looking boxes, and selling them as new. Government, hospitals, schools, and small businesses were among his customers. He had offices, eBay and Amazon storefronts, and appeared to be an entrepreneur of the highest level. After what was a decade-long investigation, the Department of Justice raided his offices, and his prosecution led to a guilty plea and prison sentence.
It’s an example of the sophisticated strategies used by counterfeiters in other aspects of the supply chain, not just counterfeiting itself. The fraud includes putting up a “storefront” and a respectable appearance that will attract serious buyers.
Johnson: In this particular example, we’re talking about a situation where an EMS company doing assembly for an OEM may find themselves accused of counterfeiting or making an inferior product that they never put together.
Das: That’s it exactly, and it’s interesting to hear you state that risk; it often does not come to our mind like that. An almost philosophical debate that occurred as we started this (and isn’t fully resolved) is when you find a circuit card (board) that an OEM verifiably makes, and yet a couple of capacitors and a resistor turn out to be counterfeit. Does that little sprinkling of parts make the entire circuit card a counterfeit? One can argue that it does. Incoming inspectors approved this product, which went through their manufacturing process. The board might even work. Surely, this can be seen as a mistake; we may not need to call the whole board counterfeit.
To read the rest of this conversation in the October 2024 issue of SMT007 Magazine, click here.
Suggested Items
Counterfeit Detection: Cybord’s Accurate One-Two Punch
11/13/2024 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007To continue the counterfeit discussion from our October issue, I recently connected with Oshri Cohen, CEO of Cybord, to discuss advancements in both counterfeit detection and data analytics. To hear Oshri describe Cybord’s work is to realize that real-time counterfeit detection technologies can also contribute directly to improving process windows in production.
Combatting Advanced Techniques in Counterfeiting
10/30/2024 | Anthony BryantIn today's interconnected global marketplace, counterfeit electronics pose a significant threat to industries ranging from aerospace and defense to healthcare and telecommunications. As counterfeiters employ increasingly sophisticated techniques, the need for robust strategies to prevent, mitigate, and identify counterfeit components has become critical. This article explores the advanced techniques used in counterfeiting, the potential involvement of state-owned enterprises (SOEs), and comprehensive strategies for combating this pervasive issue.
ERAI: The Counterfeit Watchdog
10/16/2024 | Nolan Johnson, SMT007 MagazineRick Smith is vice president of business development at ERAI, an organization founded in 1995 as a watchdog for the electronic component distribution section, aiming to combat bad business practices and counterfeiting. Rick definitely has some stories to tell about the hows and whys of counterfeiting, and breaks down some compelling numbers when it comes to fake parts being sold into the open market.
I-Connect007 Editor’s Choice: Five Must-Reads for the Week
10/11/2024 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 MagazineThis week’s roundup is a duke’s mixture of news items and interviews with industry experts from design, fabrication and assembly. There’s a lot going on in electronics now. We’ll be bringing you full coverage of SMTA International the week of Oct. 20-24, so stay tuned.
Confidee Continues to Strengthen Defense Supply Chains Through AS9120 Certification Compliance
10/10/2024 | CONFIDEEThe AS9120 certification is a quality management standard specifically designed for distributors in aviation, space and defence. It helps recognize the regulatory requirements on QMS processes, for the prevention of counterfeit and suspected unapproved parts, both in the production and aftermarket environments.