Global Citizenship: Together for a Perfect PCB Solution
Smart Automation: Odd-form Assembly—Dedicated Insertion Equipment Matters
Nolan’s Notes: Everyone Has Their Eye on India
Reliability Study of Low Silver Alloy Solder Pastes
March 1, 2016 | J. Nguyen, D. Geiger and M. Kurwa, Flextronics InternationalEstimated reading time: 17 minutes
In the SnBiAg solder joint microstructure, the majority of the solder joint consisted Bi and Sn dendrites (Figure 10f). Small grains of Ag3Sn were visible at grain boundaries, as were Cu6Sn5 particles near the solder pads. It was noticed that Bi dendrite boundary was not well defined after the reflow process.
Figure 10: SEM Images of QFN solder joint reflowed with various alloy solder pastes. a) SAC305; b) SAC0307; c) Material C; d) SnCuNi; e)Material D; f) SnBiAg.
Thermal Cycle Test Results
Results after 3000 Cycles
Table 3 summarizes the thermal cycle test results of different components reflowed using different lead-free alloy solder pastes.
Table 3: Thermal Cycle Test Results.
In general, SAC305 had a better thermal reliability than alternative low Ag alloy materials. The thermal reliability performance depended on the component types and the component design/material. Complete failure was observed for some BGA 196 components, BGA228 components, BGA97 components and resistor 2512 components after 3000 cycles (0°C to 100°C). Major cracks were seen at their solder joint. The cross section images of BGA196 solder joint after thermal cycling test are shown in Figure 11.
Figure 11: Cross section images of BGA196 components after 3000 thermal cycles. a) SAC305; b) SAC0307;c) Material C; d) SnCuNi; e) Material D; f) SnBiAg.
Most cracks happened at the component side of the package although some cracks were also observed at the PCB side. Solder joint reflowed with SnBiAg also had cracks at the interface of SAC305 solder ball and SnBiAg solder paste. The cross sections of 2512 resistors and QFN88 components after thermal cycle test were shown in Figure 12 and Figure 13, respectively. Severe cracking in the solder joint were seen for these components.
Figure 12: Cross section images of R2512 solder joint assembled using different Pb-free alloy solder pastes after 3000 thermal cycles a) SAC305; b) SAC0307; c) Material C; d) SnCuNi; e)Material D; f) SnBiAg.
Figure 13: Cross section images of QFN solder joint assembled using different Pb-free alloy solder pastes after thermal cycle testing. a) SAC305; b) SAC0307; c) Material C; d) SnCuNi; e) Material D; f) SnBiAg.
No failure was observed for some BGA components such as BGA1156 (1.0mm pitch, 35mmx35mm) and BGA64 component (0.8mm pitch, 8mm X 8mm) after thermal cycle testing. Only minor cracks were seen. The cross sections of BGA1156 component are shown in Figure 14. Minor cracking and no failure was also observed for QFP components in this study (Figure 15).
Figure 14: Cross section images of BGA1156 solder joint after thermal cycle testing. a) SAC305; b) SAC0307; c) Material C; d) SnCuNi; e) Material D; f) SnBiAg.
Figure 15: Cross section images of QFP208 solder joint assembled using different Pb-free alloy solder pastes after thermal cycle testing. a) SAC305; b) SAC0307; c) Material C; d) SnCuNi; e) Material D; f) SnBiAg.Page 3 of 5
Share on:
Testimonial
"We’re proud to call I-Connect007 a trusted partner. Their innovative approach and industry insight made our podcast collaboration a success by connecting us with the right audience and delivering real results."
Julia McCaffrey - NCAB GroupSuggested Items
Koh Young, Fuji, and Kurtz ERSA Drive Smart Manufacturing Solutions for EV and Automotive Electronics at Kunshan, China Technical Seminar
09/11/2025 | Koh YoungKoh Young Technology, the global leader in True 3D measurement-based inspection solutions, partnered with Fuji Corporation and Kurtz ERSA to host an exclusive technical seminar for leading automotive manufacturers in East China. Held on September 4 at Fuji’s factory in Kunshan, the event gathered participants representing over 35 companies.
MacDermid Alpha Presents at SMTA New Delhi, Bangalore Chapter, on Flux–OSP Interaction
09/09/2025 | MacDermid Alpha Electronics SolutionsMacDermid Alpha contributes technical insights on OSP solderability at the Bangalore Chapter, SMTA reinforcing commitment to knowledge-sharing and industry collaboration.
Electra’s ElectraJet EMJ110 Inkjet Soldermask Now in Black & Blue at Sunrise Electronics
09/08/2025 | Electra Polymers LtdFollowing the successful deployment of Electra’s Green EMJ110 Inkjet Soldermask on KLA’s Orbotech Neos™ platform at Sunrise Electronics in Elk Grove Village, Illinois, production has now moved beyond green.
Absolute EMS: The Science of the Perfect Solder Joint
09/05/2025 | Absolute EMS, Inc.Absolute EMS, Inc., a six-time award-winning provider of fast turnaround, turnkey contract electronic manufacturing services (EMS), is drawing attention to the critical role of 3D Solder Paste Inspection (SPI) in ensuring the reliability of both FLEX and rigid printed circuit board assemblies (PCBAs).
Indium Corporation to Highlight High-Reliability Solder Solutions at SMTA Guadalajara Expo
09/04/2025 | Indium CorporationIndium Corporation, a leading materials refiner, smelter, manufacturer, and supplier to the global electronics, semiconductor, thin-film, and thermal management markets, will feature a range of innovative, high-reliability solder products for printed circuit board assembly (PCBA) at the SMTA Guadalajara Expo and Tech Forum, to be held September 17-18 in Guadalajara, Mexico.