-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- pcb007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueAdvancing the Advanced Materials Discussion
Moore’s Law is no more, and the advanced material solutions to grapple with this reality are surprising, stunning, and perhaps a bit daunting. Buckle up for a dive into advanced materials and a glimpse into the next chapters of electronics manufacturing.
Inventing the Future With SEL
Two years after launching its state-of-the-art PCB facility, SEL shares lessons in vision, execution, and innovation, plus insights from industry icons and technology leaders shaping the future of PCB fabrication.
Sales: From Pitch to PO
From the first cold call to finally receiving that first purchase order, the July PCB007 Magazine breaks down some critical parts of the sales stack. To up your sales game, read on!
- Articles
- Columns
- Links
- Media kit
||| MENU - pcb007 Magazine
Happy’s Essential Skills: Benchmarking
August 3, 2016 | Happy HoldenEstimated reading time: 5 minutes

Editor's Note: Happy's columns will be published every Wednesday for the next two months.
Benchmarking is a process that measures how a company is performing against those industry leaders. It is used to better understand how outstanding companies perform, and then helps your company develop plans to improve or adapt specific best practices. Benchmarking is used to measure performance using a specific indicator (cost per unit of measure, productivity per unit of measure, cycle time of x per unit of measure or defects per unit of measure) resulting in a metric of performance that is then compared to others. A subset of benchmarking is the activity of ‘teardown.’ Many universities, as a few companies do this for profit. The most known is Portelligent[1]. David Carey, president of Portelligent. The Austin, Texas company produces teardown reports and related industry research on wireless, mobile and personal electronics and writes teardown articles for EETimes magazine. An example is seen in Figure 1.
Figure 1: Teardown benchmarking performed by Portelligent[1].
At HP, benchmarking was a very serious activity. All product lines conducted benchmarking on competitors’ products. For instruments, this was a lot easier than for a complex computer system. But in all cases, the detailed process was the same:
- Document all benchmarking activities by narrated video, high resolution camera, X-ray and microscopes
- Benchmark advertised performance using industry standards. Discover the maximum or minimum performance metrics
- Benchmark physical parameters: size, energy usage, heat produced, etc.
- Benchmark electrical parameters: power supply, number of PCBs, special electrical devices, etc.
- Benchmark the product disassembly and calculate the D&B DFM/A metrics
- Benchmark each PCB assembly: solder type, conformal coatings, heat sinks, number of parts, different part types, ICT
- Benchmark each printed circuit board: size, layers, design rules, wiring efficiency, special features-distributed capacitance
- Benchmark custom integrated circuits from each PCB, including silicon type, number of gates, design rules, etc.
- Collect all the benchmarking metrics, photos, videos and analysis into a multi-volume report from each HP organization
HP was very humble about benchmarking. It was always looking for better ideas, or exceptional performance and putting to work what it learned. Most of the time, HP exceeded other competitors’ performance, but it wanted to know how close the competitors were coming.
Benchmarking Process
The management use of the term is related to both of these, and a working definition is “the search for industry best practices that lead to superior performance.” Benchmarking is a process that aims to change operations in a structured way to achieve superior performance, based on an understanding of a company’s performance and how it compares with the best in the world. The basic philosophical steps of benchmarking, which are fundamental to success, are:
Know your operation—you need to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the internal operation, keeping in mind that competitors will in turn be analyzing your operation, and that if you don’t know your own strengths and weaknesses you will not be able to defend yourself. You need to know your strong points, to be able to promote them in the market place, and to identify areas that require strengthening.
Know the industry leaders or competitors—this helps you both to compare yourself with industry best practices and also to differentiate you from the competition.
Incorporate the best—learn from the companies who are leaders in your industry or who are particularly good in functions that are important to your operation. For example, you should compare your distribution operation with the best available mail order or service company.
Gain superiority—install the best of the best practices found, capitalize on your existing strengths and bring your weaknesses up to strength.
Benchmarking is the formalized and disciplined application of these basic steps to improving operations, as described in Figure 2. Table 1 shows some of the key reasons for benchmarking. The contrasting approaches ‘with benchmarking’ and ‘without benchmarking’ are detailed.
Figure 2: Benchmarking process steps.
Table 1: Some of the key reasons for benchmarking and the contrasting approaches with and without a benchmarking view.
Page 1 of 2
Testimonial
"Advertising in PCB007 Magazine has been a great way to showcase our bare board testers to the right audience. The I-Connect007 team makes the process smooth and professional. We’re proud to be featured in such a trusted publication."
Klaus Koziol - atgSuggested Items
Indium Corporation Earns Mexico Technology Award for New Halogen-Free Flux-Cored Wire
09/18/2025 | Indium CorporationIndium Corporation recently earned a Mexico Technology Award for its new high-reliability, halide- and halogen-free flux-cored wire, CW-807RS, which improves wetting speeds and cycle times for electronics assembly and robot soldering applications.
MacDermid Alpha Showcases Advanced Interconnect Solutions at PCIM Asia 2025
09/18/2025 | MacDermid Alpha Electronics SolutionsMacDermid Alpha Electronic Solutions, a global leader in materials for power electronics and semiconductor assembly, will showcase its latest interconnect innovations in electronic interconnect materials at PCIM Asia 2025, held from September 24 to 26 at the Shanghai New International Expo Centre, Booth N5-E30
Breakthrough in Non-Contact Solder Removal Earns Kurtz Ersa 2025 Mexico Technology Award at SMTA Guadalajara
09/18/2025 | Kurtz Ersa Inc.Kurtz Ersa Inc., a leading supplier of electronics production equipment, is proud to announce that it has been awarded a 2025 Mexico Technology Award in the category of Rework & Repair for its HR 600P Automatic Rework System.
Knocking Down the Bone Pile: Best Practices for Electronic Component Salvaging
09/17/2025 | Nash Bell -- Column: Knocking Down the Bone PileElectronic component salvaging is the practice of recovering high-value devices from PCBs taken from obsolete or superseded electronic products. These components can be reused in new assemblies, reducing dependence on newly purchased parts that may be costly or subject to long lead times.
Koh Young, Fuji, and Kurtz ERSA Drive Smart Manufacturing Solutions for EV and Automotive Electronics at Kunshan, China Technical Seminar
09/11/2025 | Koh YoungKoh Young Technology, the global leader in True 3D measurement-based inspection solutions, partnered with Fuji Corporation and Kurtz ERSA to host an exclusive technical seminar for leading automotive manufacturers in East China. Held on September 4 at Fuji’s factory in Kunshan, the event gathered participants representing over 35 companies.