Why Removing Your Bottleneck is a Bad Idea

Reading time ( words)

I received a number of comments about my column, Are Boringly Predictable Operations Possible? (February 2014). An argument repeated to me again and again was, “We don’t have a capacity problem! We have a sales problem! I have plenty of capacity!” To which I think, but do not say, “No you don’t, otherwise you wouldn’t have a sales problem.”

Let me give you an example. Let’s say you have one LDI machine for building your HDI product. This machine is only utilized 40% of the time. The orders coming off this machine generate 80% of your profits. You would tell me, “Gray, we do not have a capacity problem at LDI.”  And I would likely be unable to convince you otherwise. Let’s say you have a number of orders going through your shop that are not only HDI, but HDI quick-turn premium orders. If you complete these orders on time you will have revenue and profitability numbers for the month that will be record breakers. Then the LDI machine suddenly goes down. You have zero throughput for a week as the machine is repaired. This lack of a second machine, this extra capacity, is going to have a negative impact on your current and future sales.

You could say that isn’t what you meant about not having a capacity problem--of course having only one machine for doing critical work is risky. Then why did you let the Lean expert strip you of all excess capacity to level load and balance the production line if you knew intuitively this would increase your risk? On a recent internet search, I found this: “Line balancing is leveling the workload across all processes in a cell or value stream to remove bottlenecks and excess capacity.” The article stated, “Match the production rate after all wastes have been removed to the takt time at each process of the value stream.”

This is a very popular, yet insane thing to do.

Read the full column here.

Editor's Note: This column originally appeared in the July 2014 issue of The PCB Magazine.



Suggested Items

IPC Releases Free Smart Factory for Electronics Manufacturing Presentation

03/09/2021 | Happy Holden, I-Connect007
The IPC APEX EXPO 2021 Technical Program features a tract on the “Factory of the Future Implementation,” March 10-11. As part of that program, IPC has made available a free presentation and video from the Manufacturing Technology Center (MTC), a CFX Program member. In this presentation, Barry Maybank along with Naim Kapadia, MTC technology manager, explains the background of the MTC, one of seven high-value-manufacturing technology catapult centers established in the UK.

The Benefits of Statistical Process Control

02/17/2021 | Kurt Palmer, Bürkle North America
The concepts of statistical process control were initially developed by Dr. Walter Shewhart of Bell Laboratories in the 1920s, and were expanded upon by Dr. W. Edwards Deming, who introduced SPC to Japanese industry after WWII. After early successful adoption by Japanese firms, SPC has now been incorporated by organizations around the world as a primary tool to improve product quality by reducing process variation.

Gardien on the Right Track With New ERP System

10/29/2020 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
Andy Shaughnessy speaks with Roland Valentini, Gardien Group COO, about the company’s new OnTrack2 ERP and process management software. He explains how OnTrack2 is purpose-built for customers around the world and why it’s much more than a replacement for OnTrack1, which was being stretched beyond its original intent.

Copyright © 2021 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.