The Right Approach: Get Ready for ISO 9001 Version 6
Dan’s Biz Bookshelf: ‘Still Broke: Walmart’s Remarkable Transformation'
Driving Innovation: Depth Routing Processes—Achieving Unparalleled Precision in Complex PCBs
TQM: So Much Larger Than Quality
August 14, 2023 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamEstimated reading time: 2 minutes
A Roundtable Discussion with the I-Connect007 Editorial Team
Sit down to a conversation with industry pioneers like Happy Holden and Dan Feinberg, then add TQM proponent Barry Matties to the table, and continuous improvement eventually becomes the topic. In this roundtable discussion, the group turns to the subjects of legacy and the impact of TQM on quality, management, and business operations.
Nolan Johnson: Happy, does TQM matter today?
Happy Holden: Yes, it does. But with TQM, you can’t understand how to live it through just one course, a lecture, or even reading a book. We failed with TQM a couple of times at HP. Finally, John Young, who was president of HP at the time, reached out to W. Edwards Deming. Deming said he’d work with HP only if Young and all his VPs and operations managers were in the front row. TQM and Six Sigma programs are inspired by top-down management leadership; they're not pushed up from the bottom.
Deming emphasized that to learn TQM, you had to immerse yourself in it four times. We came up with an acronym, LUTI, which meant “learn, use, teach, inspect.” First you learn with your boss as the teacher. Then, your manager gives you a project for the “use” portion. Next, you teach it to your subordinates, and then you coach each of your subordinates on an individual project. The key was going through it four times.
It's been 45 years and I still believe in the process with TQM.
Eventually, we eliminated the final step of “inspect” by focusing on quality tests. Operators would say, “I don't think this process is working right but I don't have any tools to measure it.” So, we invented quality tests that operators could perform on the PCBs as they built them; if the test failed, they shut down the process and got the engineer, because something wasn't working right. It's interesting how few tests are developed for operators to determine the quality of a process.
As we eliminated final inspection and focused on the first pass yield electrical test, we moved everybody to the front of our process. We had to inspect all the artwork coming in because there were so many problems with the DFM portion of the printed circuit board design.
Johnson: This certainly sounds like it could be a contemporary problem as well.
Holden: Forty years after we first embraced TQM, nothing has changed in terms of the need for continuous improvement and measures of performance. We certainly have the Japanese companies continuing to live it.
To read this entire conversation, which appeared in the July 2023 issue of PCB007 Magazine, click here.
Share on:
Testimonial
"The I-Connect007 team is outstanding—kind, responsive, and a true marketing partner. Their design team created fresh, eye-catching ads, and their editorial support polished our content to let our brand shine. Thank you all! "
Sweeney Ng - CEE PCBSuggested Items
EV Group Achieves Breakthrough in Hybrid Bonding Overlay Control for Chiplet Integration
09/12/2025 | EV GroupEV Group (EVG), a leading provider of innovative process solutions and expertise serving leading-edge and future semiconductor designs and chip integration schemes, today unveiled the EVG®40 D2W—the first dedicated die-to-wafer overlay metrology platform to deliver 100 percent die overlay measurement on 300-mm wafers at high precision and speeds needed for production environments. With up to 15X higher throughput than EVG’s industry benchmark EVG®40 NT2 system designed for hybrid wafer bonding metrology, the new EVG40 D2W enables chipmakers to verify die placement accuracy and take rapid corrective action, improving process control and yield in high-volume manufacturing (HVM).
Integrating Uniplate PLBCu6 with the Digital Factory Suite
09/12/2025 | Giovanni Obino and Andreas Schatz, MKS' AtotechPrinted circuit board manufacturing is rapidly changing, driven by miniaturization, stringent reliability requirements, and growing pressure for sustainable production. Meeting these challenges requires more than incremental improvements; it demands a combination of precise equipment and real-time process intelligence. The pairing of Uniplate® PLBCu6 with the Digital Factory Suite (DFS) demonstrates how hardware and software can work together to create more responsive, resource-efficient manufacturing.
Closing the Loop on PCB Etching Waste
09/09/2025 | Shawn Stone, IECAs the PCB industry continues its push toward greener, more cost-efficient operations, Sigma Engineering’s Mecer System offers a comprehensive solution to two of the industry’s most persistent pain points: etchant consumption and rinse water waste. Designed as a modular, fully automated platform, the Mecer System regenerates spent copper etchants—both alkaline and acidic—and simultaneously recycles rinse water, transforming a traditionally linear chemical process into a closed-loop system.
The Chemical Connection: Experience and Wisdom Gained by Doing Business
09/03/2025 | Don Ball -- Column: The Chemical ConnectionA well-managed company learns to adjust its strategies and processes based on what it learns during challenging times. The experience gained from making (or losing) a difficult sale is invaluable in adapting new sales and manufacturing processes necessary to make that sale the next time, no matter how painful those new processes might be.
MacDermid Alpha Awarded for Innovation: Driving Process Optimization and Efficiency with Major Indian EMS Provider
08/28/2025 | MacDermid Alpha Electronics SolutionsMacDermid Alpha Electronics Solutions, a leading global supplier of integrated materials for the electronics industry, is recognized by one of India’s top EMS providers, Syrma SGS, with an award for innovation that advanced process optimization, enhanced operational efficiency, and yield gains.