Dan's Biz Bookshelf: 'Move Your Bus'
Driving Innovation: Direct Imaging vs. Conventional Exposure
It’s Only Common Sense: Selling to Today's Generation of Buyers
TQM: So Much Larger Than Quality
August 14, 2023 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamEstimated reading time: 2 minutes
A Roundtable Discussion with the I-Connect007 Editorial Team
Sit down to a conversation with industry pioneers like Happy Holden and Dan Feinberg, then add TQM proponent Barry Matties to the table, and continuous improvement eventually becomes the topic. In this roundtable discussion, the group turns to the subjects of legacy and the impact of TQM on quality, management, and business operations.
Nolan Johnson: Happy, does TQM matter today?
Happy Holden: Yes, it does. But with TQM, you can’t understand how to live it through just one course, a lecture, or even reading a book. We failed with TQM a couple of times at HP. Finally, John Young, who was president of HP at the time, reached out to W. Edwards Deming. Deming said he’d work with HP only if Young and all his VPs and operations managers were in the front row. TQM and Six Sigma programs are inspired by top-down management leadership; they're not pushed up from the bottom.
Deming emphasized that to learn TQM, you had to immerse yourself in it four times. We came up with an acronym, LUTI, which meant “learn, use, teach, inspect.” First you learn with your boss as the teacher. Then, your manager gives you a project for the “use” portion. Next, you teach it to your subordinates, and then you coach each of your subordinates on an individual project. The key was going through it four times.
It's been 45 years and I still believe in the process with TQM.
Eventually, we eliminated the final step of “inspect” by focusing on quality tests. Operators would say, “I don't think this process is working right but I don't have any tools to measure it.” So, we invented quality tests that operators could perform on the PCBs as they built them; if the test failed, they shut down the process and got the engineer, because something wasn't working right. It's interesting how few tests are developed for operators to determine the quality of a process.
As we eliminated final inspection and focused on the first pass yield electrical test, we moved everybody to the front of our process. We had to inspect all the artwork coming in because there were so many problems with the DFM portion of the printed circuit board design.
Johnson: This certainly sounds like it could be a contemporary problem as well.
Holden: Forty years after we first embraced TQM, nothing has changed in terms of the need for continuous improvement and measures of performance. We certainly have the Japanese companies continuing to live it.
To read this entire conversation, which appeared in the July 2023 issue of PCB007 Magazine, click here.
Share on:
Suggested Items
SMT007 Magazine July—What’s Your Competitive Sweet Spot?
07/01/2025 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamAre you in a niche that’s growing or shrinking? Is it time to reassess and refocus? We spotlight companies thriving by redefining or reinforcing their niche—what are their insights? In the July 2025 issue of SMT007 Magazine, we spotlight companies thriving by redefining or reinforcing their niche and offer insights to help you evaluate your own.
Smarter Machines Use AOI to Transform PCB Inspections
06/30/2025 | Marcy LaRont, PCB007 MagazineAs automated optical inspection (AOI) evolves from traditional end-of-process inspections to proactive, in-line solutions, the integration of AI and machine learning is revolutionizing defect reduction and enhancing yields, marking a pivotal shift in how quality is managed in manufacturing.
Magnalytix and Foresite to Host Technical Webinar on SIR Testing and Functional Reliability
06/26/2025 | MAGNALYTIXMagnalytix, in collaboration with Foresite Inc., is pleased to announce an upcoming one-hour Webinar Workshop titled “Comparing SIR IPC B-52 to Umpire 41 Functional & SIR Test Method.” This session will be held on July 24, 2025, and is open to professionals in electronics manufacturing, reliability engineering, and process development seeking insights into new testing standards for climatic reliability.
The Death of the Microsection
06/26/2025 | Bob Neves, Reliability Assessment Solutions, Inc.I got my start out of college grinding and polishing PCB microsections. My thumbs are a bit arthritic today because of the experience (microsection grinders know what I mean). Back then, via structures were rather large, and getting to the center in six steps of grinding and polishing was easy compared to what my team has been doing recently at the lab.
Specially Developed for Laser Plastic Welding from LPKF
06/25/2025 | LPKFLPKF introduces TherMoPro, a thermographic analysis system specifically developed for laser plastic welding that transforms thermal data into concrete actionable insights. Through automated capture, evaluation, and interpretation of surface temperature patterns immediately after welding, the system provides unprecedented process transparency that correlates with product joining quality and long-term product stability.