Marcy’s Musings: The Legislative Outlook—Helping or Hurting?
It’s Only Common Sense: The Phone Is Still Mightier Than the Keyboard
The Marketing Minute: Marketing With Layers
TQM: So Much Larger Than Quality
August 14, 2023 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamEstimated reading time: 2 minutes
A Roundtable Discussion with the I-Connect007 Editorial Team
Sit down to a conversation with industry pioneers like Happy Holden and Dan Feinberg, then add TQM proponent Barry Matties to the table, and continuous improvement eventually becomes the topic. In this roundtable discussion, the group turns to the subjects of legacy and the impact of TQM on quality, management, and business operations.
Nolan Johnson: Happy, does TQM matter today?
Happy Holden: Yes, it does. But with TQM, you can’t understand how to live it through just one course, a lecture, or even reading a book. We failed with TQM a couple of times at HP. Finally, John Young, who was president of HP at the time, reached out to W. Edwards Deming. Deming said he’d work with HP only if Young and all his VPs and operations managers were in the front row. TQM and Six Sigma programs are inspired by top-down management leadership; they're not pushed up from the bottom.
Deming emphasized that to learn TQM, you had to immerse yourself in it four times. We came up with an acronym, LUTI, which meant “learn, use, teach, inspect.” First you learn with your boss as the teacher. Then, your manager gives you a project for the “use” portion. Next, you teach it to your subordinates, and then you coach each of your subordinates on an individual project. The key was going through it four times.
It's been 45 years and I still believe in the process with TQM.
Eventually, we eliminated the final step of “inspect” by focusing on quality tests. Operators would say, “I don't think this process is working right but I don't have any tools to measure it.” So, we invented quality tests that operators could perform on the PCBs as they built them; if the test failed, they shut down the process and got the engineer, because something wasn't working right. It's interesting how few tests are developed for operators to determine the quality of a process.
As we eliminated final inspection and focused on the first pass yield electrical test, we moved everybody to the front of our process. We had to inspect all the artwork coming in because there were so many problems with the DFM portion of the printed circuit board design.
Johnson: This certainly sounds like it could be a contemporary problem as well.
Holden: Forty years after we first embraced TQM, nothing has changed in terms of the need for continuous improvement and measures of performance. We certainly have the Japanese companies continuing to live it.
To read this entire conversation, which appeared in the July 2023 issue of PCB007 Magazine, click here.
Share on:
Testimonial
"In a year when every marketing dollar mattered, I chose to keep I-Connect007 in our 2025 plan. Their commitment to high-quality, insightful content aligns with Koh Young’s values and helps readers navigate a changing industry. "
Brent Fischthal - Koh YoungSuggested Items
The Marketing Minute: Marketing With Layers
10/15/2025 | Brittany Martin -- Column: The Marketing MinuteMarketing to a technical audience is like crafting a multilayer board: Each layer serves a purpose, from the surface story to the buried detail that keeps everything connected. At I-Connect007, we’ve learned that the best marketing campaigns aren’t built linearly; they’re layered. A campaign might start with a highly technical resource, such as an in-depth article, a white paper, or a podcast featuring an engineer delving into the details of a process. That’s the foundation, the substance that earns credibility.
Taking Control of PCB Verification One Step at a Time
10/09/2025 | Kirk Fabbri, Siemens EDAToday’s designs are as complex as ever, and engineers face tough decisions every day. Simulation and verification teams are confronted with a three-fold challenge: understanding the underlying theory, mastering the tools, and applying best practices.Engineers need to navigate a vast and ever-changing cast of design and simulation tools, often with overlapping functionality.
Happy’s Tech Talk #43: Engineering Statistics Training With Free Software
10/06/2025 | Happy Holden -- Column: Happy’s Tech TalkIn over 50 years as a PCB process engineer, the one skill I acquired in college that has been most beneficial is engineering statistics. Basic statistics was part of my engineering fundamentals classes, but I petitioned the dean to let me take the engineering statistics graduate course because I was creating a senior thesis for my honors focus and needed more training on Design of Experiments (DOE).
Connect the Dots: Evolution of PCB Manufacturing—Lamination
10/02/2025 | Matt Stevenson -- Column: Connect the DotsWhen I wrote The Printed Circuit Designer's Guide to...™ Designing for Reality, it was not a one-and-done effort. Technology is advancing rapidly. Designing for the reality of PCB manufacturing will continue to evolve. That’s why I encourage designers to stay on top of the tools and processes used during production, to ensure their designs capitalize on the capabilities of their manufacturing partner.
Empower Sets New Benchmark with 20x Faster Response and Breakthrough Sustainability Demonstrated at OCP Global Summit 2025
09/25/2025 | Empower SemiconductorEmpower Semiconductor, the world leader in powering AI-class processors, announced that its Crescendo chipset, an artificial intelligence (AI) and high-performance computing (HPC) processor true vertical power delivery platform, is available now for final sampling, with mass production slated for late 2025.