Global Sourcing Spotlight: Finding the Balance Between Cost and Quality
Knocking Down the Bone Pile: Best Practices for Electronic Component Salvaging
Global Citizenship: Together for a Perfect PCB Solution
What’s Your Process for Developing a Strategy?
August 24, 2023 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamEstimated reading time: 3 minutes
Dr. Tim Rodgers might not call himself a “business strategies guru,” but the moniker certainly fits. As an adjunct faculty instructor at the University of Colorado, Tim specializes in project management, problem-solving, and streamlining processes in engineering and manufacturing. Plus, Tim knows the business side of PCB fabrication.
We asked Tim to discuss the process of developing a successful business strategy for PCB fabricators, why operational efficiency is not a strategy itself, and how smaller companies can differentiate themselves in an industry that’s becoming more and more commoditized.
Andy Shaughnessy: Tim, would you share your thoughts on developing a business strategy?
Tim Rodgers: Sure. This is hugely important for companies to understand. We see a lot of examples of companies that fail because they don't have a clear strategy. It really should start with asking, “How do you choose to compete? What can you do to create sustainable competitive advantage?” Companies that don't have a clear strategy just zigzag back and forth. They take a lot of actions, and they may be very busy, but their actions are not consistent with any kind of strategic strategy. So, they end up expending resources without really getting anywhere.
One of the big challenges for PCB fabricators is trying to figure out how to differentiate themselves, and that's really difficult. So many fabricators are basically the same; they use the same manufacturing processes, the same operating model, and there's not a lot of opportunity for differentiation. There are still breakthroughs in production capabilities and operating models, but it's getting harder and harder because the whole industry is becoming “commoditized,” and when you start selling the same thing that everybody else is selling, then the power shifts to the buyer; the buyer has the power to basically do price comparisons. It’s a difficult situation to be in.
A lot of what we teach about strategy comes from the work of Harvard Business School Professor Michael Porter. About 30 years ago, he published his idea that there are really three different ways to compete. One is based on differentiation, another is based on cost leadership, and the final way is appealing to a niche market of some kind. Cost leadership basically means we will make the same thing, and provide the same services that everybody else provides, but we'll do it at a lower cost. We will beat everybody on cost. Walmart and Southwest Airlines figured out how to compete at very low cost and they can compete very effectively on that basis.
Differentiation means we will offer a product or service that is different, and customers will buy from us because we provide something they can't get somewhere else. A great example of that kind of strategy comes from Apple, which has a very clear differentiation around its operating system. I'm a Mac user, and I can get a cheaper PC, but we Mac users choose to spend more money in order to get what we think is a differentiated experience. The real question is how we can apply that to the world of printed circuit board fabrication.
The third one is niche. Can you appeal to a particular niche? If you can, your business will be small because it's a niche market of some kind, but it could be quite profitable. A good example of that might be trying to appeal to a specific kind of market, maybe medical devices, for example, manufacturers for the medical device industry have to submit to audits of their manufacturing practices. If you choose to specialize in this particular market, you may not get very big, but this strategy can help ensure competitive advantage in that niche market.
To read this entire conversation, which appeared in the August 2023 issue of PCB007 Magazine, click here.
Share on:
Testimonial
"Advertising in PCB007 Magazine has been a great way to showcase our bare board testers to the right audience. The I-Connect007 team makes the process smooth and professional. We’re proud to be featured in such a trusted publication."
Klaus Koziol - atgSuggested Items
Global Sourcing Spotlight: Finding the Balance Between Cost and Quality
09/24/2025 | Bob Duke -- Column: Global Sourcing SpotlightIn global sourcing, pursuing lower costs often takes center stage. It’s the shiny lure that gets buyers to cast their lines into unfamiliar waters. But seasoned professionals know that in the long run, sourcing is less about price tags and more about value. The real magic—and margin—lies in finding the balance between cost and quality.
I-Connect007 Editor’s Choice: Five Must-Reads for the Week
08/15/2025 | Marcy LaRont, I-Connect007In our industry, my top reads include Prashant Patel’s overview and argument for reshoring, which I found to be a great general overview and breakdown. In further support of the onshoring/reshoring message, I’m highlighting Nolan Johnson’s interview on the survey and report by the Reshoring Initiative. Check out my interview with USPAE’s Jim Will on the state of the flat panel display (FPD) industry and the risks associated with it for U.S. defense and critical infrastructure products.
Global Electronics Industry Remains Under Pressure from Rising Costs
08/04/2025 | Global Electronics AssociationThe global electronics manufacturing supply chain remains under pressure from rising costs, with 61% of firms reporting higher material costs and 54% noting increased labor expenses. according to the Global Electronics Association’s Sentiment of the Global Electronics Manufacturing Supply Chain Report.
Statement from the Global Electronics Association on the July 2025 Tariff on Copper Foil and Electronics-Grade Copper Inputs
07/31/2025 | Global Electronics AssociationWe are disappointed by today’s decision to impose a 50% tariff on imported copper foil and other essential materials critical to electronics manufacturing in the United States.
Direct Metallization: A Sustainable Shift in PCB Fabrication
07/31/2025 | Jim Watkowski, Harry Yang, and Mark Edwards, MacDermid Alpha Electronics SolutionsThe global electronics industry is undergoing a significant transformation, driven by the need for more resilient supply chains and environmentally sustainable manufacturing practices. Printed circuit boards (PCBs), the backbone of interconnection for electronic devices, are at the center of this shift. Traditionally, PCB fabrication has relied heavily on electroless copper, a process that, while effective, is resource-intensive and environmentally hazardous. In response, many manufacturers are turning to direct metallization technologies as a cleaner, more efficient alternative.