Dan's Biz Bookshelf: 'Revenge of the Tipping Point'
Marcy's Musings: Engineering Economics
Punching Out: Should You Sell Your Company to a Private Equity Firm?
The Designer and Manufacturer Must Be in Sync
February 7, 2024 | Dana Korf, Korf ConsultancyEstimated reading time: 1 minute
“Why can’t we all just get along?”—Henry Liberman, TEDx
It’s no industry secret that most PCB data packages sent to fabricators from designers cannot be built as-is. The finished boards often seem to work, despite a factory estimating what the designer wanted vs. what the documentation showed, then jointly rectifying issues through lengthy technical query (TQ) cycles. In general, everyone seems to be satisfied with this process, so why do we need to improve the designer/manufacturer relationship? Why is the best solution a strong designer/manufacturer relationship, and is it even possible?
Let’s perform a traditional root cause analysis and define the function of a designer vs. a manufacturer. Oxford Language definitions:
Designer: A person who plans the form, look, or workings of something before its being made or built, typically by drawing it in detail.
Manufacturer: A person or company that makes goods for sale.
This seems pretty straightforward. The manufacturer builds the product based on the supplied documentation. Unfortunately, the manufacturer’s front-end engineering team typically completes a portion of the design after the data package is received because it can’t be built as submitted. The manufacturer must update the design to maximize yield, meet cost targets, ensure reliability, and meet all performance requirements.
Typical design functions performed by the manufacturer include creating a material stackup that meets the specified mechanical thicknesses/tolerances, material selection, line width/spacing modification to generate the specified impedance/tolerance, creating the assembly array/panel design/documentation, and ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements, such as UL.
To read this entire article, which appeared in the January 2024 issue of PCB007 Magazine, click here.
Share on:
Suggested Items
It’s Only Common Sense: Results Come from Action, Not Intention
11/11/2024 | Dan Beaulieu -- Column: It's Only Common SenseEverybody has an excuse, and especially in business, there’s no shortage. Every day we hear why something didn’t work, a target wasn’t met, or an opportunity was missed. Excuses are easy. Action is hard. If you want to achieve results, stop making excuses and start acting. It’s only common sense.
Real Time with... SMTAI 2024: LPKF Laser Depaneling—Debunking the Heat Myth
10/29/2024 | Real Time with...SMTAILPKF's Jake Benz shares the testing results he presented at the SMTAI conference showing that laser depaneling is not a significant source of heat to PCBAs. Benz goes into details why.
It's Only Common Sense: The Election Isn’t Your Problem
10/21/2024 | Dan Beaulieu -- Column: It's Only Common SenseHow many times have you heard, “We’re just waiting to see how the election turns out before we make any decisions?” Having been in this business for a while, I can tell you that’s nonsense. Blaming your lack of sales or slow customer decisions on the election is the biggest cop-out. It’s an excuse, plain and simple, and one that keeps you from facing the real issues. Here are 10 reasons why the election has nothing to do with it.
Danish-founded Defense Group Aims for More Responsibility Within Defense Supply Chain
09/09/2024 | CONFIDEEUnder the slogan "Together We Are Stronger," the AS9100 Nordic Consortium unites a powerful network of committed Danish companies, along with one Norwegian partner. This collaboration strives to elevate the defense and aerospace industries through a shared focus on traceability and quality management.
It’s Only Common Sense: Hear That? It’s Opportunity Knocking
08/26/2024 | Dan Beaulieu -- Column: It's Only Common SenseI was reading the Sunday comics the other day when I came across a statement in “Hi and Lois” or maybe it was “Arlo and Janis” — one of those deep philosophical comic strips. One character says to the other, “He’s the kind of guy that when he hears opportunity knocking, he complains about the noise.” I love that. Not only because it’s funny, but because it’s also true.