-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- pcb007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueSales: From Pitch to PO
From the first cold call to finally receiving that first purchase order, the July PCB007 Magazine breaks down some critical parts of the sales stack. To up your sales game, read on!
The Hole Truth: Via Integrity in an HDI World
From the drilled hole to registration across multiple sequential lamination cycles, to the quality of your copper plating, via reliability in an HDI world is becoming an ever-greater challenge. This month we look at “The Hole Truth,” from creating the “perfect” via to how you can assure via quality and reliability, the first time, every time.
In Pursuit of Perfection: Defect Reduction
For bare PCB board fabrication, defect reduction is a critical aspect of a company's bottom line profitability. In this issue, we examine how imaging, etching, and plating processes can provide information and insight into reducing defects and increasing yields.
- Articles
- Columns
- Links
- Media kit
||| MENU - pcb007 Magazine
Happy’s Essential Skills: Problem Solving
February 24, 2016 | Happy HoldenEstimated reading time: 4 minutes

Related to TQC and a very important role of an engineer is solving problems. Using a problem solving methodology is a job that all engineers will use sooner or later, but if you are in product or process engineering in manufacturing, it will be sooner! This was the situation that introduced me to printed circuit manufacturing.
I started at Hewlett-Packard in the very new department of integrated circuit manufacturing. What a wild environment that was in 1970! After six months of orientation and familiarization, the bosses came to me one day with an urgent offer: “You are our only chemical engineer and we are in a crisis in our new printed circuit manufacturing plant. Will you go down the hill and help solve the process problems that are plaguing them?”
“Sure,” I said. “What are printed circuits?”
He answered, “They’re just large integrated circuits!”
I went down the hill (from Page Mill Road to Porter Drive in Palo Alto), solved their process problems in a few weeks…and never left! I had two tools the electrical and mechanical engineers in the PCB plant didn’t have: engineering statistics, including design of experiments (DOE—more in the next column) and experience with problem solving—TQC.
In electronics manufacturing today, problems in production will involve numerous customers. Customer communication is essential. The timing of this communication depends on how quickly the supplier is expected to correct the issue. Feedback should be specific and detailed, including part number, lot number, invoice, date received, and supporting evidence such as photographs and test results if available. The supplier will need this information to conduct an investigation of root cause and develop a corrective action plan.
For serious quality problems that generate scrap or rework, customers will insist that the supplier submit a written document that describes the investigation and corrective actions, or a corrective action report (CAR). The purpose of the document is to provide a record of the problem solving, and establish confidence that the supplier has successfully addressed the issue and that the issue will not recur.
When selecting a problem solving process, it is important to understand when you should—and should not—use structured problem solving. Therefore, an understanding of problem solving methodology is crucial. Once you have selected a process to use, be sure to document and communicate progress throughout the project.
Already written about in this column is the TQC PDCA Process: Plan—Do—Check—Act. Also, the six-sigma DMAIC process: Define—Measure—Analyze—Improve—Control. Familiar to many of you would be the general scientific method:
- Define the question/make observations
- Gather information and facts
- Form hypothesis
- Perform experiments and collect data
- Analyze data
- Interpret data and draw conclusions
- Summarize results
A common methodology used by many suppliers is ‘Eight Disciplines Problem Solving’ (8D), created by the U.S. Department of Defense and popularized by Ford (Table 1), and the CAR based on this process is sometimes referred to as an 8D report. Another popular methodology is the ‘7-Step Problem Resolution Process’, attributed to Toyota and described in Table 2.
My favorite is the problem solving methodology that is taught by Kepner-Tregoe[1]. This is a rigorous three-day course, usually referred to as KT, which has expanded the problem solving processes into four areas: Situation Appraisal—Problem Analysis—Decision Analysis—Potential Problem Analysis (Figure 1). Its three action sequences (Figure 2) summarize the important steps in the KT process.
Figure 1: Kepner-Tregoe Problem Solving Process©® (courtesy Kepner-Tragoe).
Figure 2: Kepner-Tregoe Problem Action Sequence©® (courtesy Kepner-Tragoe).
Page 1 of 2
Testimonial
"We’re proud to call I-Connect007 a trusted partner. Their innovative approach and industry insight made our podcast collaboration a success by connecting us with the right audience and delivering real results."
Julia McCaffrey - NCAB GroupSuggested Items
Designers Notebook: Basic PCB Planning Criteria—Establishing Design Constraints
07/22/2025 | Vern Solberg -- Column: Designer's NotebookPrinted circuit board development flows more smoothly when all critical issues are predefined and understood from the start. As a basic planning strategy, the designer must first consider the product performance criteria, then determine the specific industry standards or specifications that the product must meet. Planning also includes a review of all significant issues that may affect the product’s manufacture, performance, reliability, overall quality, and safety.
Marcy’s Musings: From Pitch to PO—The Sales Stack
07/21/2025 | Marcy LaRont -- Column: Marcy's MusingsIt is a foundational truth that a company lives and dies by its sales. Receiving that PO or contract starts the operational chain. It is the purest symbol of the machinations of the business process: You are paying me for something I am doing, making, or sourcing for you. Then, every single thing a business does in executing and fulfilling that sales agreement speaks directly to customer experience and whether more POs will follow. You won't keep customers if you don't make a quality product and provide strong customer service.
July 2025 PCB007 Magazine: Sales—From Pitch to PO
07/18/2025 |Though all parts of a company are essential for holistic success, it is a foundational truth that a company lives and dies by its sales. If there are no sales, the company eventually ceases to exist, or as Henry Ford says, “Nothing happens until someone sells something.” In the July issue of PCB007 Magazine, we break down the sales stack and provide a guide to up your sales game.
Tightening of LPDDR4X Supply Drives Up Prices; Smartphone Brands to Accelerate Adoption of LPDDR5X
07/17/2025 | TrendForceTrendForce’s latest investigations reveal that major Korean and U.S. memory suppliers are expected to significantly reduce or even cease production of LPDDR4X in 2025 and 2026.
Beyond Design: Refining Design Constraints
07/17/2025 | Barry Olney -- Column: Beyond DesignBefore starting any project, it is crucial to develop a thorough plan that encompasses all essential requirements. This ensures that the final product not only aligns with the design concept but is also manufacturable, reliable, and meets performance expectations. High-speed PCB design requires us to not only push technological boundaries but also consider various factors related to higher frequencies, faster transition times, and increased bandwidths during the design process.