-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- pcb007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueDon’t Just Survive, Thrive
If we are to be relevant and prosper during these next critical decades in electronics, we must do more than survive. As an industry, we can and must thrive. In this issue, our contributors explore these concepts meant to help you take your business to the next level.
Material Matters
Materials management is nuanced, multifaceted, and requires a holistic systems approach for business success. When building high mix, low volume, and high technology, managing materials and overall cost containment are even greater challenges.
Additive Manufacturing
In this month’s issue, we explore additive manufacturing technology for the PCB fabricator: where it stands today, the true benefits, and where it seems to be headed.
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Events
||| MENU - pcb007 Magazine
Happy's Essential Skills: Metrics and Dimensional Analysis
October 5, 2016 | Happy HoldenEstimated reading time: 7 minutes
![](https://iconnect007.com/application/files/4417/1686/6064/happy_holden_col_300.jpg)
After reading 20 of my columns, by now you probably realize that I am an analytical person. Thus, I dedicate this column to the topic of metrics—the method of measuring something. I mentioned the four levels of metrics in my column entitled Producibility and Other Figures of Merit back in June of this year. Additionally, I introduced the five stages of metrics in the second part of the following column, Design for Manufacturing and Assembly, Part 2 later that same month. This column completes the discussion of metrics with the subject of dimensionless quantities.
The use of a dimensionless quantity is a common way to study a wide variety of physical phenomena or engineering problems. A dimensionless equation, algebraic or differential, involves variables without physical dimensions. For example, most people prefer to know the Mach number rather than the speed because it's easier to compare performance. These numbers (coefficients or factors) are part of the physical world and exist in many applications. More than 1200 dimensionless quantities are used in science, economics, medicine, geophysics and ecology. Avogadro’s number is one used in chemistry. This column will talk only about those used in engineering for thermodynamics, thermomechanics, fluid mechanics, solid mechanics and electromagnetics.
Why?
These numbers or factors are essential in modern industry and science. These numbers are the Figure of Merit that I describe in Column #9. They allow us to quantify those physical or mental activities that otherwise would fall into the realm of opinion or conjecture. One that I have used for the last 40 years for printed circuit fabrication is the complexity index. This index allows me to model (from design information) the first pass yield in PCB fabrication with only a 3−7% error.[1–3]. Using this process, many other factors can be created that will simplify working with complex systems in design, fabrication or assembly. Use the process any place where you need to measure something that right now is just an opinion.
Dimensional Systems
Every numerical characteristic used in engineering comprises three elements:
- name
- magnitude
- dimension
There are two types of dimensions: fundamental and derived. Fundamental dimensions cannot be expressed in terms of other dimensions, and they serve as building blocks for more complex, derived dimensions.
Sometimes, a group of fundamental dimensions has a dedicated name, which is then called a unit. A special class of units are those with a dimension of one, which result when all the fundamental dimensions of the unit cancel. Although not entirely accurate, such units are called dimensionless parameters. These units are frequently called number, ratio, index, factor, effect, or coefficient. Examples include Mach number, Slenderness ratio, Toms effect, Reynolds number, and friction coefficient. The advantage of these absolute numbers is that their numerical values are independent of the dimensional system used.
All dimensional systems in use today can be classified according to whether they use the metric or American/British system and whether they use force or mass as a fundamental dimension. Force-based systems include the metric MKS force and American/British engineering systems. Mass-based systems include the SI and British mass systems.
- MKS: Fundamental dimensions are meter (m), kilogram (kg), and second (s), where kg means force. Mass has a derived dimension of kg-s2/m. Until recently, this system was widely used in engineering in continental Europe and is still favored by many there.
- American/British engineering: Fundamental dimensions are foot (or inch), pound (lb), and second, where lb means force. Accordingly, the dimensions of mass are lb-s2/ft (also called the slug) or lb-s2/in.
- SI: Fundamental dimensions are kilogram (for mass), meter, and second. Force is a derived dimension, with the unit Newton. SI actually has seven fundamental dimensions, and also includes ampere, degrees Kelvin, mole, and candella.
- British Mass: Here, pound is the dimension of mass and is legally equivalent to 0.45359237 kg in SI. Force is a derived dimension, and its unit is poundal, which is numerically equivalent to the force necessary to impart l-ft./s2 acceleration to a 1-lb mass. One poundal is equivalent to 0.138254954 kg-m/s2 in SI, which is nearly 0.5 oz. in the American/British engineering system.
Mass-based systems have the advantage that this dimension is independent of the numerical value of gravitational acceleration g, which even at sea level can vary as much as 0.5% with latitude. Therefore, the use of a mass-based system is uniform anywhere in the universe.
On the other hand, having mass as a fundamental dimension is impractical in everyday life because mass cannot be directly perceived or measured. Rather, mass must be determined indirectly by subjecting it to a known inertial or gravitational acceleration and measuring the force generated.
Dimensional Analysis
In engineering, dimensional analysis is the analysis of the relationships between different physical factors/quantities by using their fundamental dimensions (such as mass, length, time, electrical charge, or temperature, etc.) and unit of measure (such as Fahrenheit vs. Centigrade, miles vs. kilometers, or pounds vs. kilograms) and comparing these dimensions as calculations. Converting from one-dimensional unit to another is often somewhat complex. Dimensional analysis, or more specifically the factor-label method, also known as the unit-factor method, is a widely used technique for such conversions using the rules of algebra.
From a discussion on ResearchGate[4], the Professor Issam Sinjab commented, “But on a more abstract level, dimensional analysis allows you to abstract over a wide variety of phenomena, and gives insight to regimes where some parameters vanish and can be ignored. The Reynolds number in hydrodynamics is a good example of this. At very low Reynolds number, many terms in the equations vanish, and thus systems can be approximated by very simple equations (laminar flow) even though flow at all Reynolds numbers is fundamentally governed by the Navier-Stokes equation.”
For another interesting example of this, the mathematician G. I. Taylor used dimensionless forms of certain equations to figure out highly classified and secret information about the atomic bomb in the 1940s.
The purposes of dimensionless equations are:
- To simplify the equation(s) by reducing the number of variables used
- To analyze system behavior regardless of the unit used to measure variables
- To rescale parameters and variables so that all computed quantities are of same order (relatively similar magnitudes)
- To scale-up physical systems from experiment to production
The concept of physical dimension was introduced by Joseph Fourier in 1822. Physical quantities that have the same common measure have the same dimension; if they have different dimensions, they are incommensurable. For example, it is pointless to ask whether a gram is less, the same, or more than a minute. Page 1 of 2
Suggested Items
Enhance Your Electronics Expertise Through IPC Courses in August
07/25/2024 | Corey Lynn, IPCAs the global leader in standards, training, and certification for the electronics industry, IPC is pleased to announce an array of upcoming online instructor-led courses this August. These courses are designed to equip professionals with the latest skills and knowledge required to excel in the ever-evolving field of electronics manufacturing and design. Whether you want to deepen your expertise in PCB design and manufacturing, understand the intricacies of intermetallic compounds, or learn about counterfeit part mitigation, IPC has a course tailored for you.
The Knowledge Base: The Value of Industry Certifications
07/24/2024 | Mike Konrad -- Column: The Knowledge BaseIndustry certifications have become increasingly significant in the modern job market, offering a range of benefits to both individuals and employers. These certifications serve as formal recognitions of expertise and proficiency in specific areas, validating a person's skills and knowledge. In the context of the electronics assembly industry, certifications are particularly valuable, given the technical nature of the work and the rapid advancements in technology.
Tom Edman Leads IPC Board of Directors
07/17/2024 | Marcy LaRont, PCB007 MagazineIPC elected several new board members at IPC APEX EXPO in April, including new Board Chair Tom Edman, CEO of TTM, who assumes the role from Bob Neves, CTO and chair of Microtek Laboratories. Tom and TTM have long been active in many facets of IPC. I caught up with Tom and asked him about his new board appointment, IPC, and the industry he serves. He emphasizes IPC’s work in standards and advocacy as especially important for our industry.
Getting Clear About Certification With Charlie Capers
07/17/2024 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamWalk through the entrance at Zentech Dallas and you’ll see a wall of certification plaques prominently displayed. Beyond being impressive and a point of pride, these certifications tell a story to potential customers: This company is ready to do business. Charlie Capers, former vice president and general manager, shares his insights on quantifying the ROI of certifications. You may not see it on paper, but it’s definitely there. He also talks about his expectations for new hires and shares a case study about the importance of collaborating with your PCB designers.
Winners of 2024 IPC Masters Competition China Announced
07/17/2024 | IPCFrom July 8-10, the 2024 IPC Masters Competition China was successfully held in Pudong, Shanghai. This year’s competition, was the largest in the history of the Greater China region, bringing nearly 400 electronics industry elites from 18 provinces and municipalities.