It’s Only Common Sense: Build Your Business on Reputation, Not Neglect
The Marketing Minute: If Your Marketing Budget Gets Cut in Half, Then What?
Punching Out: How Are the Big Boys in Electronics Doing?
X-Ray Inspection of Lead and Lead-Free Solder Joints
July 31, 2017 | Glen Thomas, Ph.D., and Bill Cardoso, Ph.D., Creative Electron Inc.Estimated reading time: 10 minutes
where Emax is the maximum energy in the spectrum, which is 150keV for the X-ray machine used in this paper.
TIN-LEAD SOLDER VS. LEAD-FREE SOLDERS
There are a number of lead-free solder compounds in the market today. For examples in this analysis we used some of the solder compounds discussed in [5]. In particular, we compare eutectic tin-lead solder (63Sn/37Pb), tin-bismuth (42Sn/58Bi), and a variety of predominantly tin based solders, including tin-silver (98Sn/2Ag), tin-antimony (95Sn/5Sb), tin-indium-silver (77.2Sn/10In/2.8Ag), and tin-silver-copper (96.3Sn/3.2Ag/0.5Cu).
Solder compounds can be classified according to those he deems most likely lead-free alternatives, all of which have at least 95% Sn content[5]. In our analysis, we consider three of these (98Sn/2Ag, 95Sn/5Sb, and 96.3Sn/3.2Ag/0.5Cu). The others are provided for comparison purposes. Equation 4 must be discretized for evaluation. Using a Creative Electron’s proprietary emulation and simulation software, we computed the energy spectra and attenuation coefficients for 16 bands of 10keV width spanning 10keV to 160keV. Equation 4 in discrete form then becomes:
Using this data and accounting for filtration due to the X-ray source anode materials, we obtain values for all p(Ei ). The results are summarized in Figure 5. In Figure 6 we provide the stopping power (i.e., 1-I/I0) for five lead-free solder compounds and eutectic tin-lead solder at thicknesses of 2 mil, 5 mil, 10 mil, and 20 mil. The stopping power indicates the relative amount of X-rays that are attenuated in the material. For example, a stopping power of 0.75 means that three-quarters of the incident radiation is attenuated. Higher numbers consequently imply higher attenuation.
Figure 5: Energy spectrum of a TruView FUSION with a 150kV microfocus X-ray source.
Figure 6: Attenuation of lead-free solders and eutectic tin-lead solder. Note that the amount of attenuation at different material thicknesses is similar.
X-RAY IMAGE ANALYSIS
To validate the analysis presented in the previous session our Advanced Technology Group inspected a wide range of samples with both lead and lead-free solder composites. We compared eutectic tin-lead (63Sn/37Pb) and tin-bismuth (42Sn/58Bi) solders for their imaging profile using a TruView FUSION running at a maximum of 150kV. As expected, the X-ray images obtained from the samples using both types of solder did not present a notable difference. Please note that it is not the focus of this paper to compare the overall performance between lead and lead-free solders. Instead, the objective of this analysis is to validate that the X-ray machine settings work for both lead and lead-free solders.
Figure 7: Gullwing solder joints using both lead and leadfree solder paste. Note that the lead-free solder is slightly lighter (less dense) than the lead solder joint.
Page 3 of 5
Share on:
Testimonial
"Advertising in PCB007 Magazine has been a great way to showcase our bare board testers to the right audience. The I-Connect007 team makes the process smooth and professional. We’re proud to be featured in such a trusted publication."
Klaus Koziol - atgSuggested Items
Indium Experts to Address Data Center Thermal Management and Sintering Standards at SMTA Conference
05/13/2026 | Indium CorporationAs a leading materials provider for the advanced electronic packaging market, Indium Corporation® experts will share their technical insight and knowledge on two critical industry topics—data center thermal management and sintering protocols—at the SMTA Electronics in Harsh Environments Conference, May 19-21, in Amsterdam, Netherlands.
KYZEN to Focus on Aqueous and Stencil Cleaning Solutions at SMTA Juarez Expo and Tech Forum
05/12/2026 | KYZENKYZEN, the global leader in innovative environmentally friendly cleaning chemistries, will exhibit at the SMTA Monterrey Expo & Tech Forum scheduled to take place on Thursday, May 21 at Injectronics Convention Center in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua.
Knocking Down the Bone Pile: Precision Milling of Underfilled SMT Components
05/13/2026 | Nash Bell -- Column: Knocking Down the Bone PileUnderfill is a polymeric material used to fill the gap between a printed circuit board and the underside of surface-mount area-array packages such as BGA, QFP, and QFN devices, thereby surrounding and protecting the solder interconnections. This material increases the component's reliability when subjected to mechanical impacts and shocks by distributing forces.
BGA Technology Expands Inspection Capabilities with Creative Electron TruView X-ray System
05/08/2026 | BGA TechnologyBGA Technology, a leading provider of advanced electronics testing and inspection services, has enhanced its inspection capabilities with the addition of a Creative Electron TruView™ Simplex X-ray system at its Holbrook, New York facility.
AQUANOX A4727 and A4625 Lead KYZEN Offerings at SMTA Oregon Expo and Tech Forum
05/06/2026 | KYZENKYZEN, the global leader in innovative environmentally responsible cleaning chemistries, will exhibit at the SMTA Oregon Expo and Tech Forum scheduled to take place Thursday, May 19 at the Wingspan Event and Conference Center in Hillsboro, Oregon.