It’s Only Common Sense: Build Your Business on Reputation, Not Neglect
The Marketing Minute: If Your Marketing Budget Gets Cut in Half, Then What?
Punching Out: How Are the Big Boys in Electronics Doing?
X-Ray Inspection of Lead and Lead-Free Solder Joints
July 31, 2017 | Glen Thomas, Ph.D., and Bill Cardoso, Ph.D., Creative Electron Inc.Estimated reading time: 10 minutes
Figure 12: Oblique view of a BGA assembled using lead-free solder. Note the size and shape of the balls in the first row. The balls on the left are correctly connected, while the balls on the last column in the right are either open or head-in-pillow (HIP). This side view indicates a planarity problem with this assembly, which means that the BGA must be removed and reworked.
Figure 13: Lead solder BGA with several of its balls showing excessive voiding which indicate that this part should be reworked. The irregular shape of some of the balls suggests irregular reflow.
Figure 14: Lead-free solder BGA with several of its balls showing excessive voiding which indicate that this part should be reworked.
CONCLUSIONS
In this paper, we demonstrated some effects on an X-ray inspection system the imaging characteristics for a few of the lead-free solders. A theoretical analysis based upon X-ray attenuation characteristics showed that there is almost no difference between eutectic tin-lead solder and 42Sn/58Bi. We also determined that predominantly Sn based solders lead to a contrast about 88% of that for eutectic tin-lead solder. Consequently, we expect little variation in the inspectability of joints made with these alternative solders. We additionally provided some images of real solder joints constructed with these different compounds. These images showed the expected contrast variations.
Although the analysis performed in this paper does not constitute a rigorous proof, it indicates that usage of a number of lead-free solders should not seriously degrade the X-ray inspection imaging capability.
REFERENCES
1. Hupfer, M., Nowak, T., Brauweiler, R., Eisa, F., and Kalender, W.A. (2012). “Spectral optimization for micro-CT”. Med. Phys.39, 3229–3239.
2. Attix, Frank H. “Introduction to Radiological Physics and Radiation Dosimetry”. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1986.
3. Cullen, D. E., et. al. “Tables and Graphs of Photon-Interaction Cross Sections Derived from the LLNL Evaluated Photon Data Library (EPDL), Z=1-50”. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA, Vol. 6, Part A, Rev. 4, 1991.
4. Cullen, D. E., et. al. “Tables and Graphs of Photon-Interaction Cross Sections Derived from the LLNL Evaluated Photon Data Library (EPDL), Z=50-100”. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA, Vol. 6, Part B, Rev. 4, 1991.
5. Bastecki, Chris. “A Benchmark Process for the Lead-Free Assembly of Mixed Technology PCBs”. Technical Brief, Alpha Metals Inc., January 1997.
Editor's Note: This paper was originally published in the proceedings of SMTA International, 2016.
Page 5 of 5Share on:
Testimonial
"Advertising in PCB007 Magazine has been a great way to showcase our bare board testers to the right audience. The I-Connect007 team makes the process smooth and professional. We’re proud to be featured in such a trusted publication."
Klaus Koziol - atgSuggested Items
Indium Experts to Address Data Center Thermal Management and Sintering Standards at SMTA Conference
05/13/2026 | Indium CorporationAs a leading materials provider for the advanced electronic packaging market, Indium Corporation® experts will share their technical insight and knowledge on two critical industry topics—data center thermal management and sintering protocols—at the SMTA Electronics in Harsh Environments Conference, May 19-21, in Amsterdam, Netherlands.
KYZEN to Focus on Aqueous and Stencil Cleaning Solutions at SMTA Juarez Expo and Tech Forum
05/12/2026 | KYZENKYZEN, the global leader in innovative environmentally friendly cleaning chemistries, will exhibit at the SMTA Monterrey Expo & Tech Forum scheduled to take place on Thursday, May 21 at Injectronics Convention Center in Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua.
Knocking Down the Bone Pile: Precision Milling of Underfilled SMT Components
05/13/2026 | Nash Bell -- Column: Knocking Down the Bone PileUnderfill is a polymeric material used to fill the gap between a printed circuit board and the underside of surface-mount area-array packages such as BGA, QFP, and QFN devices, thereby surrounding and protecting the solder interconnections. This material increases the component's reliability when subjected to mechanical impacts and shocks by distributing forces.
BGA Technology Expands Inspection Capabilities with Creative Electron TruView X-ray System
05/08/2026 | BGA TechnologyBGA Technology, a leading provider of advanced electronics testing and inspection services, has enhanced its inspection capabilities with the addition of a Creative Electron TruView™ Simplex X-ray system at its Holbrook, New York facility.
AQUANOX A4727 and A4625 Lead KYZEN Offerings at SMTA Oregon Expo and Tech Forum
05/06/2026 | KYZENKYZEN, the global leader in innovative environmentally responsible cleaning chemistries, will exhibit at the SMTA Oregon Expo and Tech Forum scheduled to take place Thursday, May 19 at the Wingspan Event and Conference Center in Hillsboro, Oregon.