-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- smt007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueComing to Terms With AI
In this issue, we examine the profound effect artificial intelligence and machine learning are having on manufacturing and business processes. We follow technology, innovation, and money as automation becomes the new key indicator of growth in our industry.
Box Build
One trend is to add box build and final assembly to your product offering. In this issue, we explore the opportunities and risks of adding system assembly to your service portfolio.
IPC APEX EXPO 2024 Pre-show
This month’s issue devotes its pages to a comprehensive preview of the IPC APEX EXPO 2024 event. Whether your role is technical or business, if you're new-to-the-industry or seasoned veteran, you'll find value throughout this program.
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Events
||| MENU - smt007 Magazine
Clean vs. No-clean Solder Process
July 3, 2019 | Russell Poppe, JJS ManufacturingEstimated reading time: 4 minutes
IPC, which was founded in 1957 as the Institute for Printed Circuits, is the trade association responsible for standardizing the assembly and production requirements of electronic equipment and assemblies.
Although IPC suggests clear guidelines, agreeing on the cleanliness (or otherwise) of a PCB assembly can often be a subjective and even contentious subject within the electronics manufacturing industry.
If you’ve chosen to outsource your assemblies, how do you decide what to specify to your EMS partner?
Defining "Clean" in PCB Assembly
Firstly, it’s probably worth defining what "clean" actually means. I think we're on safe ground to assume that lumps of unwanted debris or particulate matter—mysterious white residues or corrosion of any kind—are obviously not allowed.
Such things not only make the assembly look untidy, but they can also damage the functionality or long-term reliability of the product. Most of the time, when we’re talking about "cleanliness," we're referring to flux residues.
It is possible, to an extent, to measure cleanliness. For example, once an assembly has been cleaned, you can measure the residues in the cleaning process cycles to ensure the desired maximum has been achieved. However, for many—perhaps most—electronics applications, it’s often more about the cosmetic finish or other process considerations.
As you might imagine, when we start to talk about solders, fluxes, and cleaning agents, there is quite a bit of chemistry going on. But for now, let's focus on the practical issues surrounding whether an assembly should be cleaned or not.
To Clean or Not to Clean?
Why clean in the first place? Obviously, there are cosmetic considerations to keep in mind. If a no-clean flux is used during the SMT process, the assembly should look perfectly fine, as most of the flux gets burned off during the process.
However, if there is through-hole soldering afterwards—particularly hand soldering—it can show small areas of flux that make it all look a bit untidy due to the extra flux that is typically applied and the reduction in both heat and time associated with hand soldering compared to SMT ovens.
Perhaps most importantly, any residues must not interfere with visual inspection. If there is anything left obscuring solder joints, for example, then it must be cleaned off either by hand or by using one of the automated cleaning machines available.
If the product is to be tested using test probes, such as in-circuit test or flying probe, then flux can cause unreliability if the probes can’t access their test points on the PCB. This is usually fine if a pin-testable flux is used, but any excesses may need to be cleaned off.
If the assembly is to have a conformal coating, then all flux residues must be removed before application, so the PCBA will have to go through a cleaning process.
Are there any situations where you might choose not to clean? Well, yes. Some fluxes are designed to be cleaned off, but some aren't. Again, neatly side-stepping the chemistry here if the flux is designed to stay on the PCB then trying to clean it off generally isn't a good idea.
There is also an argument that the flux can provide a harmless protective layer over the solder joints and that removing it can expose the PCB finish to problems later.
Naturally, there are cost implications too. Cleaning is an additional process, so it's going to have a value attached to it. And there is also the impact on the environment with additional water or chemical supplies needed, which then need to be disposed of correctly.
It's also worth bearing in mind that certain types of components simply can't be cleaned due to the risk of the cleaning agent getting inside the body of the device and causing damage.
If cleaning is required, it can also overly complicate the build process—for example, having to fit components after the main clean, then individually cleaning those components, or by adding extra drying stages.
Again, any extra processes are going to mean additional cost.
Which Cleaning Method is Best?
What are your options when it comes to cleaning? Here are three:
- Localized cleaning: Can be achieved with a brush and cleaning agent such as IPA. However, care must be taken to ensure the residue is cleaned off and not simply spread thinly across the assembly.
- Automated solutions: There are some that use water (very similar to a dishwasher) or other cleaning agents, depending on the flux used. These cleaners tend to be relatively small in terms of physical footprint and the waste can usually be disposed of down existing on-site drains.
- Ultrasonic cleaners: These tend to be larger in size, cost more, and due to the chemicals used, will require specialist handling of the waste that is produced to ensure it is disposed of safely. There are, however, certain components that can't be cleaned using this equipment.
Many electronics manufacturing services (EMS) providers now standardize on a no-clean process. If you are unsure, or you are weighing up the pros and cons, then it’s always best to take advice from your EMS partner. They know what your requirements are—and they'll have the experience, equipment, skills, and processes in place to meet your demands.
Russell Poppe is the director of technology at JJS Manufacturing.
Suggested Items
Connect the Dots: Designing for Reality—The Pre-Manufacturing Process
05/08/2024 | Matt Stevenson -- Column: Connect the DotsI have been working with Nolan Johnson on a podcast series about designing PCBs for the reality of manufacturing. By sharing lessons learned over a long career in the PCB industry, we hope to shorten learning curves and help designers produce better boards with less hassle and rework. Episode 2 deals with the electronic pre-manufacturing process. Moving from CAD (computer-aided design) to CAM (computer-aided manufacturing) is a key step in PCB manufacturing. CAM turns digital designs into instructions that machines can use to actually build the PCB.
AIM Solder Signs Shinil Fl Ltd. as New Distributor for Korea
05/08/2024 | AIM SolderAIM Solder, a leading global manufacturer of solder assembly materials for the electronics industry, is pleased to announce a new distribution partnership with Shinil Fl Ltd., a prominent supplier of technological solutions in the SMT and semiconductor sectors.
Indium Corporation to Showcase HIA Materials at ECTC
05/07/2024 | Indium CorporationAs an industry leader in innovative materials solutions for semiconductor packaging and assembly, Indium Corporation® will feature its advanced products designed to meet the evolving challenges of heterogeneous integration and assembly (HIA) and fine-pitch system-in-package (SiP) applications at the 74th Electronic Components and Technology Conference (ECTC), May 28‒31, in Denver, Colorado.
Indium Corporation Expert to Present on Pb-Free Solder for Die-Attach in Discrete Power Applications
04/30/2024 | Indium CorporationIndium Corporation Product Manager – Semiconductor Dean Payne will present at the Advanced Packaging for Power Electronics conference, hosted by IMAPS, held May 8-9 in Woburn, Massachusetts, USA.
Taiyo Circuit Automation Installs New DP3500 into Fuba Printed Circuits, Tunisia
04/25/2024 | Taiyo Circuit AutomationTaiyo Circuit Automation is proud to be partnered with Fuba Printed Circuits, Tunisia part of the OneTech Group of companies, a leading printed circuit board manufacturer based out of Bizerte, Tunisia, on their first installation of Taiyo Circuit Automation DP3500 coater.