-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- design007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueThe Designer of the Future
Our expert contributors peer into their crystal balls and offer their thoughts on the designers and design engineers of tomorrow, and what their jobs will look like.
Advanced Packaging and Stackup Design
This month, our expert contributors discuss the impact of advanced packaging on stackup design—from SI and DFM challenges through the variety of material tradeoffs that designers must contend with in HDI and UHDI.
Rules of Thumb
This month, we delve into rules of thumb—which ones work, which ones should be avoided. Rules of thumb are everywhere, but there may be hundreds of rules of thumb for PCB design. How do we separate the wheat from the chaff, so to speak?
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Media kit
||| MENU - design007 Magazine
Six Money-saving Material Properties When Designing PCB Stackups
March 13, 2023 | Patrick Hope, Siemens Digital Industry Software, Sponsored ContentEstimated reading time: 4 minutes
Stackup decisions are critical to every PCB and electronic product, but they don’t always get the attention they deserve. With better stackup planning focusing on six key parameters, designers can select the best materials early in the design process and minimize the risk of under- and overdesigning their PCB.
Dielectric Material Selection
A typical dielectric material sheet will have multiple pages of specs with dozens of parameters for consideration. Cutting through the noise to get to the essence of the material’s properties is hugely beneficial when it comes to material selection. While every spec listed will have a circumstantial purpose, in essence, there are essentially three groups to consider: electrical properties, thermal properties, and mechanical properties.
Many of the mechanical properties like moisture absorption, Young’s Modulus, peel strength, and Poisson’s Ratio are important in specific circumstances. Making concise dielectric material comparisons should focus on six electrical and thermal properties: Dk, Df, Tg, Td, XY-CTE, and Z-CTE.
Video #1: Introduction
Electrical Parameters
Dielectric constant (Dk) and dissipation factor (Df) values are directly related, forming a balancing act within the board as their values directly reflect the ratio between the resin and glass within the material. Understanding the relationship between these electrical parameters and the resin percentage within your material will go a long way toward helping you make decisions about your materials.
Determining the Dk and Df values of your dielectric is usually a straightforward process within any stackup calculator once the loss budget and target thickness have been set, but assessing and assembling these values can be difficult.
Laminate vendors give each resin system a unique datasheet for each resin content available, with values typically listed at 1 Ghz. The Dk and Df values will drift within each option, as the overall resin content will vary. It’s probably easier to view the laminate vendor’s table values than it is to scour all their datasheets. If you are dealing with more than just a handful of materials, the best alternative is to use a materials library which provides these values across multiple resin ratios and with multiple materials and at any frequency.
This goes a long way to simplifying this issue, providing values among multiple resin ratios, as well as at multiple frequencies.
Video #2: Electrical Parameters
Thermal Parameters
When examining the required thermal parameters of your materials, like decomposition temperature (Td) and transition temperature (Tg), PCB assembly is the largest factor. The European Union’s Restriction on the Use of Hazardous Substances (RoHs) directive has had an impact on thermal parameters as the lead-free solder required today has a higher melting point than tin-lead materials, and therefore temperatures during assembly or rework can reach >260°C multiple times. Thicker boards need higher temperatures to bond properly so it’s better to choose high glass-transition-temperature materials and materials with comparatively low z-CTEs for them.
When looking at Tg values, there are three ways to measure what is essentially the same attribute, and vendors will use any one of these ways to measure what is essentially the same data point.
1. Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA)
The best method to use is the dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) method. It detects changes in the storage modulus and loss modulus (Tg: peak temperature of the tan delta; IPC TM-650 Method 2.4.24.2).
2. Differential Scanning Calorimeter (DSC)
The next best method is differential scanning calorimeter (DSC), which measures the flow of heat into or out of a sample while the sample is heated (Tg: temperature at half height of step change in heat flow; IPC TM-650 Method 2.4.25).
3. Thermomechanical Analysis (TMA)
The last method is thermomechanical analysis, which measures changes in the height of the sample vs. temperature (Tg: temperature where CTE changes; IPC TM-650 Method 2.4.24.24, 2.4.24.5).
If you are designing a thinner board, manufacturers can save 25% or more on material costs by using mid-Tg materials, which can be a critical cost-saver in high-volume production.
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion (CTE)
These values represent the XY coefficient of thermal expansion and the z-axis coefficient of thermal expansion. They are different values and the practical application for this information is different, but the concept behind them is the same.
Excessive x,y (horizontal) expansion caused from high temperatures often leads to misalignment of BGAs, causing solder joint failure, while excessive z-axis (vertical) expansion can lead to barrel cracking.
Video #3: Thermal Parameters
Over Design: The Hidden Cost of Your Board
Being able to locate points of saving within these six material attributes allows you to explore other options and gets you out of your comfort zone, which is where the real savings lie. Improving performance in any one of these values represents an increase in cost from your laminate vendor. Digging deep into your board requirements and understanding where you can cut overall costs can be quite beneficial.
Laminate prices are never advertised, so understanding the relational costs really come from aggregate data from multiple suppliers, or from internal understanding of the pricing structure. Understanding and seeing these cost savings may require working in-depth with your laminate vendors.
Video #4: Over Designing
For more information on material properties, material selection, and building the most cost-effective, robust stackup, please download Stackups: The Design within the Design.
Try a free trial of our Z-planner Enterprise, our powerful stackup planning software. Z-planner Enterprise allows you to evaluate and compare hundreds of dielectric materials and find suggested alternatives based on your board’s requirements.
Suggested Items
AIM to Participate in SMTA Ultra High Density Interconnect Symposium
01/15/2025 | AIMAIM Solder, a leading global manufacturer of solder assembly materials for the electronics industry is pleased to announce its participation in the SMTA Ultra High Density Interconnect (UHDI) Symposium, taking place on January 23, 2025 at the Peoria Sports Complex in Peoria, Arizona.
Technica Installs CBT/MLI Direct Imaging System at Summit Interconnect Santa Clara
01/14/2025 | Technica USATechnica has recently installed the 6th CBT/MLI Direct Imaging (DI) system at Summit Interconnect's Santa Clara operation, a testament to Summit's ongoing commitment to cutting-edge technology and operational excellence.
Indium to Showcase Power Electronics Products at NEPCON Japan
01/14/2025 | Indium CorporationAs one of the leading materials providers in the electronics assembly industry, Indium Corporation® is proud to feature its lineup of high-reliability products for power electronics at NEPCON Japan, taking place January 22-24, in Tokyo, Japan.
SolderKing to Highlight Innovations in Soldering and Manufacturing Efficiency at Southern Manufacturing & Electronics 2025
01/08/2025 | SolderKing Assembly Materials Ltd,SolderKing, a leading UK manufacturer of advanced soldering materials and consumables, will be exhibiting at the Southern Manufacturing and Electronics Show from 4-6 February 2025 at the Farnborough International Exhibition Centre, Stand J90.
Altus Highlights Heller Industries Advances in Void Reduction Under 1%
01/06/2025 | Altus GroupAltus Group, a leading distributor of capital equipment in the UK and Ireland, emphasises the importance of reducing voids in reflow soldering to improve manufacturing efficiency and product reliability