-
-
News
News Highlights
- Books
Featured Books
- smt007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueWhat's Your Sweet Spot?
Are you in a niche that’s growing or shrinking? Is it time to reassess and refocus? We spotlight companies thriving by redefining or reinforcing their niche. What are their insights?
Moving Forward With Confidence
In this issue, we focus on sales and quoting, workforce training, new IPC leadership in the U.S. and Canada, the effects of tariffs, CFX standards, and much more—all designed to provide perspective as you move through the cloud bank of today's shifting economic market.
Intelligent Test and Inspection
Are you ready to explore the cutting-edge advancements shaping the electronics manufacturing industry? The May 2025 issue of SMT007 Magazine is packed with insights, innovations, and expert perspectives that you won’t want to miss.
- Articles
- Columns
- Links
- Media kit
||| MENU - smt007 Magazine
Time to Ditch Heavy Metal for Soft Rock?
April 8, 2015 | Yash Sutariya and Thomas TarterEstimated reading time: 3 minutes

I've been writing on thermal management for LED applications for a few years now, seemingly on an endless quest to find the next best thing for LED PCBs. It's been kind of like Indiana Jones and his search for the Holy Grail, except I don't have cool bullwhip skills. To date, we've focused on calculating thermal management needs as well as explore other alternatives to MCPCBs to achieve thermal management, such as standard plated through holes in FR4 material. I'd say at this point the industry has reached a saturation point when it comes to knowledge on how to dissipate heat (of course you never know what’s around the corner).
I think now it's time to move on to a topic that we've overlooked when it comes to PCBs for LEDs: reliability! I think the reason we've overlooked reliability is because it is traditionally associated with via life under thermal cycling conditions. Since most LED PCBs are single sided, this really hasn't been an issue. However, if you look above the waterline, there is another weak link—the solder joint. Some OEMs in the industry have been performing studies on the life of their LED products. While the bulbs themselves are said to have useful lives in excess of 30+ years, they are finding out that the actual LED assemblies can fail in as little as 5–6 years. Initial analysis is pointing to the significant X and Y axes CTE differences between the solder joint, copper circuitry layer, thermally conductive dielectric, and the aluminum. The net result of the CTE differences is a shear effect being created that can eventually disrupt the solder joint, which results in operational failure.
Depending upon how accurate this information is, it could mean the start of a whole new approach to PCBs for LED applications. Below is an abstract of a white paper written by Thomas Tarter from Package Science Services, which performed initial testing on carbon fiber and graphite based materials provided by Stablcor Technology Inc. The carbon fiber constraining cores (CFCC) materials evaluated are carbon-fiber and/or graphite reinforced epoxy cores to aid in heat dissipation, rigidity, weight reduction, and CTE control. These cores can be used independently or in conjunction with current MCPCBs to produce functionally improved heat dissipation while reducing the CTE mismatch currently present on LED assemblies.
Abstract: Introduction and Model Parameters (by Thomas Tarter)
Thermal performance for PCB structures are investigated in the form of steady-state finite element models of various stack-ups of commonly used materials for LED applications. The models show the effect of materials used in the stack up including FR-4, aluminum, copper, graphite and CFCC. The goal of the study is to compare relative thermal behavior of typical boards modified with the enhanced core materials.
The materials are inserted into standard PCB stack-up configurations as an added or replaced layer. Models are solved for maximum temperature on a 25 mm x 25 mm coupon with a 2 mm x 2 mm-square heat source. The stack up resembles substrates known as "metal-clad" where the dielectric and topside copper are laminated directly onto a metal substrate. In addition, FR4 boards are used as a worst-case comparison.
Variables used in the study include material properties and layer thickness. The primary variables are top side copper thickness/weight, dielectric thickness and base material thickness. Table 1 lists the ranges for geometry and material properties. The heat source is simulated as a planar load, directly on the surface of the top-layer copper. One watt is applied over a 2mm x 2 mm square area in the center of the coupon. The models are solved in natural convection with an ambient temperature of 30°C.
Editor's Note: This article originally appeared in the March issue of SMT Magazine.
Suggested Items
Silicon Mountain Contract Services Enhances SMT Capabilities with New HELLER Reflow Oven
07/17/2025 | Silicon Mountain Contract ServicesSilicon Mountain Contract Services, a leading provider of custom electronics manufacturing solutions, is proud to announce a significant upgrade to its SMT production capability with the addition of a HELLER 2043 MK5 10‑zone reflow oven to its Nampa facility.
Knocking Down the Bone Pile: Addressing End-of-life Component Solderability Issues, Part 4
07/16/2025 | Nash Bell -- Column: Knocking Down the Bone PileIn 1983, the Department of Defense identified that over 40% of military electronic system failures in the field were electrical, with approximately 50% attributed to poor solder connections. Investigations revealed that plated finishes, typically nickel or tin, were porous and non-intermetallic.
SHENMAO Strengthens Semiconductor Capabilities with Acquisition of PMTC
07/10/2025 | SHENMAOSHENMAO America, Inc. has announced the acquisition of Profound Material Technology Co., Ltd. (PMTC), a premier Taiwan-based manufacturer of high-performance solder balls for semiconductor packaging.
KYZEN to Highlight Understencil and PCB Cleaners at SMTA Querétaro Expo and Tech Forum
07/09/2025 | KYZEN'KYZEN, the global leader in innovative environmentally responsible cleaning chemistries, will exhibit at the SMTA Querétaro Expo & Tech Forum, scheduled to take place Thursday, July 24, at Centro de Congresos y Teatro Metropolitano de Querétaro.
Driving Innovation: Direct Imaging vs. Conventional Exposure
07/01/2025 | Simon Khesin -- Column: Driving InnovationMy first camera used Kodak film. I even experimented with developing photos in the bathroom, though I usually dropped the film off at a Kodak center and received the prints two weeks later, only to discover that some images were out of focus or poorly framed. Today, every smartphone contains a high-quality camera capable of producing stunning images instantly.