Elementary Mr. Watson: Running the Signal Gauntlet
The Shaughnessy Report: Winning the Signal Integrity Battle
Connect the Dots: How to Avoid Five Common Causes of Board Failure
This Month in Design007 Magazine: HDI Design, Landless Vias, VeCS, and More
November 9, 2020 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamEstimated reading time: 2 minutes
Andy Shaughnessy, Happy Holden, and Dan Feinberg recently met with James Hofer, general manager of Accurate Circuit Engineering, to discuss via design techniques and via reliability from the fabricator’s viewpoint. As Hofer explained, even with open lines of communication between the designer and the board shop, there are plenty of variables to contend with regarding proper via design, especially when working with PTFE materials.
Andy Shaughnessy: James, start by telling us some of the problems that you see with failures in vias and microvias.
James Hofer: I face a couple of challenges. Designers tend to want to do HDI designs with laser-drilled vias with aspect ratios of 1.5:1 or 1.8:1, or they want to do laser-drilled vias through multiple layers without removing pads. I don’t yet have a reliable copper-fill process that gives me as flat a surface fill as I want. As you know, most of our product is PTFE. Stacking laser vias on PTFE and copper-filled vias presents a couple of challenges. I see more and more customers want a PTFE dielectric, and they want to put a 4- or a 6-mil via in it. That presents issues both in the drilling of the via and with the plating of the via. I see a lot of that, so I find myself trying to redo designs after the fact with most customers.
Shaughnessy: They’re trying to use HDI when they don’t necessarily need it.
Hofer: And when they don’t necessarily understand some of the give and take that goes with it. They don’t want to abide by some basic principles and rules that we manufacturers have to live by.
Happy Holden: Why would they get into HDI but not do any basic investigation on how to optimize drills or design with it?
Hofer: I agree. That’s exactly what we face.
Holden: Or they read about it or heard about it, and they’re going to use it, even though they don’t know anything about it.
Hofer: That sums it up right there. The majority read something about it. Perhaps they read the first couple of paragraphs of one of Happy’s articles and think, “Great, I can do this,” and then off they go. It is far more appropriate to discuss with the manufacturer before you implement the technology.
Holden: The HDI Handbook is free. It goes into reliability and plating and metallization, materials, aspect ratio, and cycle integrity.
Dan Feinberg: Why wouldn’t they read it and use some of those recommendations? That’s a good investment.
Holden: Or just type HDI into Google or Yahoo.
Shaughnessy: Don’t designers communicate with you beforehand? I know they say they’re going to talk to their fabricator, but do they really?
Hofer: No. We face that problem pretty much on a daily basis.
To read this entire interview, which appeared in the November 2020 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.
Share on:
Testimonial
"The I-Connect007 team is outstanding—kind, responsive, and a true marketing partner. Their design team created fresh, eye-catching ads, and their editorial support polished our content to let our brand shine. Thank you all! "
Sweeney Ng - CEE PCBSuggested Items
Trouble in Your Tank: Implementing Direct Metallization in Advanced Substrate Packaging
09/15/2025 | Michael Carano -- Column: Trouble in Your TankDirect metallization systems based on conductive graphite are gaining popularity throughout the world. The environmental and productivity gains achievable with this process are outstanding. Direct metallization reduces the costs of compliance, waste treatment, and legal issues related to chemical exposure. A graphite-based direct plate system has been devised to address these needs.
Closing the Loop on PCB Etching Waste
09/09/2025 | Shawn Stone, IECAs the PCB industry continues its push toward greener, more cost-efficient operations, Sigma Engineering’s Mecer System offers a comprehensive solution to two of the industry’s most persistent pain points: etchant consumption and rinse water waste. Designed as a modular, fully automated platform, the Mecer System regenerates spent copper etchants—both alkaline and acidic—and simultaneously recycles rinse water, transforming a traditionally linear chemical process into a closed-loop system.
Driving Innovation: Depth Routing Processes—Achieving Unparalleled Precision in Complex PCBs
09/08/2025 | Kurt Palmer -- Column: Driving InnovationIn PCB manufacturing, the demand for increasingly complex and miniaturized designs continually pushes the boundaries of traditional fabrication methods, including depth routing. Success in these applications demands not only on robust machinery but also sophisticated control functions. PCB manufacturers rely on advanced machine features and process methodologies to meet their precise depth routing goals. Here, I’ll explore some crucial functions that empower manufacturers to master complex depth routing challenges.
Trouble in Your Tank: Minimizing Small-via Defects for High-reliability PCBs
08/27/2025 | Michael Carano -- Column: Trouble in Your TankTo quote the comedian Stephen Wright, “If at first you don’t succeed, then skydiving is not for you.” That can be the battle cry when you find that only small-diameter vias are exhibiting voids. Why are small holes more prone to voids than larger vias when processed through electroless copper? There are several reasons.
The Government Circuit: Navigating New Trade Headwinds and New Partnerships
08/25/2025 | Chris Mitchell -- Column: The Government CircuitAs global trade winds continue to howl, the electronics manufacturing industry finds itself at a critical juncture. After months of warnings, the U.S. Government has implemented a broad array of tariff increases, with fresh duties hitting copper-based products, semiconductors, and imports from many nations. On the positive side, tentative trade agreements with Europe, China, Japan, and other nations are providing at least some clarity and counterbalance.