-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- design007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueThe Designer of the Future
Our expert contributors peer into their crystal balls and offer their thoughts on the designers and design engineers of tomorrow, and what their jobs will look like.
Advanced Packaging and Stackup Design
This month, our expert contributors discuss the impact of advanced packaging on stackup design—from SI and DFM challenges through the variety of material tradeoffs that designers must contend with in HDI and UHDI.
Rules of Thumb
This month, we delve into rules of thumb—which ones work, which ones should be avoided. Rules of thumb are everywhere, but there may be hundreds of rules of thumb for PCB design. How do we separate the wheat from the chaff, so to speak?
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Media kit
||| MENU - design007 Magazine
8 Simple Rules for Streamlining Your Design
November 30, 2023 | Chris Young, Young Engineering ServicesEstimated reading time: 5 minutes
There are many ways, dozens to be sure, and most likely many more, to streamline a PCB design. My goal here is to pick a single-digit number of rules to abide by, that can be reasonably adhered to, and provide some bang for the buck. These rules are meant to reduce design scope creep, avoid PCB respins, and improve production yields.
1: Communicate clearly.
Use explicit communication when addressing ambiguous items. Test point placement can seem like an ambiguous task. Statements like, “Find room for test points,” do not help to define scope or draw boundaries. Instead, try statements like, “Production test points can only be on a single side of the PCB in order to reduce test fixture complexity.” Implicit communication should be reserved for well-defined objectives and processes. An example would be instructing a PCB designer to place test points per the design procedures identified by company policy X, paragraph Y.
2: Proceed with a common goal in mind.
Designing on the fly without a mutually agreed upon set of goals is a catalyst for scope creep and technical debt. A design blitz, as in football, is a defensive high-risk maneuver intended to reduce schedule (offensive) pressure. Instead, take the time needed to establish a well-defined and measurable set of design goals. Include the project stakeholders, get buy in, and then execute.
3: Design your PCB power delivery system (PDS).
Your PCB power delivery system (power planes/structures) should be based on your power distribution requirements and not a coincidence of layout. This means that your PDS design should take place before settling on a board stackup. A typical PDS is composed of discrete capacitors, power plane capacitance, and on-chip capacitance. Determining the amount of plane capacitance needed for a specific design should involve the use of a simulator such as HyperLynx, ADS, or HFSS. Designing an appropriate PDS for your board design is easy to say, much harder to do, and very much worth your time. Improper or poorly implemented PDS designs are nearly impossible to recover from without a costly board respin.
4: Know your drill holes.
A PCB can play host to many types of drill holes for various reasons. A few examples are vias, mounting holes, tooling holes, and press fit holes. Vias come in many forms, but they tend to be some type of plated hole that is typically used for signal, ground, or power transitions from one PCB layer to another. Vias can also be used for thermal conduction between PCB layers. It is important to understand that mechanical engineers typically regard mounting and tooling holes as two very different types of holes that serve entirely different purposes. Mounting holes can be plated or non-plated and provide a clearance/loose fit for the PCB so that it may be attached to some other structure. Tooling holes are designed and manufactured to a tight tolerance so they can provide a transition fit needed for precise alignment of a PCB in an assembly or test fixture. PCBs use interference fit holes for press fit connectors. The connector/PCB mating pins interfere slightly with the holes on the PCB, requiring force to be applied to the connector during the mating process instead of soldering the pins to the PCB itself. Knowing the types of drill holes used on your PCB and their purposes allows designers to effectively communicate their purposes to other stakeholders in a project.
5: Coordinate your design with your fabricator.
The last thing you want to hear from a PCB fabricator is that they are no-bidding your design because it is not compatible with their capabilities. It is perfectly reasonable to include your PCB fabricator in your design reviews. Making sure that your design fits within the manufacturing capabilities of your fabricator is a primary objective, not an “on the side” project. Furthermore, your PCBs built for production should be well within fabricator’s range of capabilities and should not be pushing their edges so that your yields (major PCB cost driver) are not driven by process variations.
6: Consult with the group or company assembling your boards.
It is best to know what practical limitations your assembly process imposes on your design instead of finding out post assembly. Not all pick-and-place machines are created equal. Accuracy of small component placement can vary greatly between different pick-and-place machines. Manually removing assembled boards from panels can damage shock-sensitive components. The risks associated with whoever may be assembling your boards can be mitigated by simply involving them in your design review process.
7: Document your component library process.
A well-documented CAD library process reduces the chances of errors when creating parts. Part requests should include the part number, manufacturer, part description, datasheet(s), priority level, need date, package type, part type, and any descriptive information or notes for symbol or footprint creation. The part that is created to fulfill the request should be documented and linked to the request. The part should then be reviewed and documented as either meeting the request or as needing to be reworked. The documentation could take the form of a spreadsheet, database, or even a physical paper trail. The intent is to explicitly communicate what parts need to be created and how.
8: Test point placement is critical.
PCB test points serve to support design and production. Circuit designers will use test points to assist in integration and verify functionality. Test points are typically used in production to load software/firmware and verify proper PCB assembly. Production using test points should take precedence over design and engineering test points. Test point locations directly impact the complexity of test fixture design, so strive to place them on only one side of the PCB. Do not place components on the opposite side of a PCB underneath a test point. This provides space on the PCB to apply an opposing force to reduce stress and strain on the board assembly when test points are engaged during test. Don’t find space for test points. Make space by performing test point placement alongside component placement.
Resources
- “Power Delivery System Design,” by Lee Ritchey, Altium.
- Simulators – Keysight ADS, Siemens EDA HyperLynx, Ansys HFSS.
- Chris Young is founder and president of Young Engineering Services.
This article originally appears in the November 2023 issue of Design007 Magazine.
Suggested Items
TSK Schill GmbH Closes 2024 With a Record Turnover
01/14/2025 | TSK Schill GmbHAt TSK, the course continues to be set for growth. Despite the turbulent market development, we were able to increase our turnover “EBIT”. We generated a large proportion of our turnover with Solution Business.
January 2025 Issue of Design007 Magazine: The Designer of the Future
01/13/2025 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamAs we enter the new year, it’s a great time to be a PCB designer. The job is more complex than ever, and a lot of fun too. We can only wonder what the PCB designers of 1975 would think about the typical PCB designer’s workday. What will the designers' job be like for the next generations?
The Shaughnessy Report: The Designer of Tomorrow
01/14/2025 | Andy Shaughnessy -- Column: The Shaughnessy ReportIt’s a great time to be a PCB designer. The job is more complex than ever, but it's also a lot of fun. We can only wonder what the PCB designers of 1975 would think about today’s typical workday. What will the designer's job look like in the future? There has been a move toward working remotely, driven partly by the COVID pandemic and partly by reality: Many experienced designers simply will not relocate, even for a more lucrative job.
I-Connect007 Editor’s Choice: Five Must-Reads for the Week
01/10/2025 | Marcy LaRont, I-Connect007In the past couple of weeks, we’ve had some big industry news. In the automotive world, Honda and Nissan merged to form the largest car manufacturer in Japan. Before President Biden left office, he made sure to distribute more CHIPS Act money to bring some measure of electronics manufacturing back to the U.S. And former President Jimmy Carter died at the age of 100 and was honored on Thursday, reminding us all what true integrity looks like.
IPC Announces New Training Course: PCB Design for Manufacturability
01/10/2025 | IPCThis three-week online program, taught by an industry expert with over 40 years of experience, is designed to equip PCB designers with the knowledge and skills to reduce or eliminate design, documentation, and capability issues that often arise during PCB fabrication.