Beyond Design: High-speed Rules of Thumb
Global PCB Connections: A Technical Overview of Long-flex Printed Circuit Boards
The Shaughnessy Report: A Handy Look at Rules of Thumb
The Survey Said: What Does It Take to Become a Great Designer?
March 14, 2024 | Andy Shaughnessy, PCB Design007Estimated reading time: 1 minute
There are thousands of good PCB designers around the world. But the number of truly great designers makes up a much smaller universe.
What does it take to become a great designer? After all, there isn’t exactly a critical path to becoming a great designer. How does a designer qualify as “great” in the first place?
We posed that question to our PCB designer readers in a recent survey, and, as usual, the readers did not disappoint. These are a few of the more illustrative answers, edited slightly for clarity.
1. Great designers have a love for layout and plenty of experience. Training is not helpful, but mentoring is very valuable.
2. You need to have a broad knowledge of the physics behind the process—metallurgy, chemistry, mechanics, and electronics—and the interaction between opposing issues (which ones should be given priority over another).
3. It takes experience and the ability to communicate with both designers and production engineers closely.
4. I personally think a great PCB designer should start with basic drafting skills and basic electronics. Learn everything you can about PCB fabrication, assembly and test. Then jump back in and learn in-depth electronic applications, maybe focusing on a desired field. We should not expect engineers with tons of application skills and minimal PCB knowledge to create great PCB layouts.
5. Learning from those with the proven ability to design optimal PCBs is the best way to gain from the experience of others. However, is there a reluctance on the part of those with experience to pass it on to the next generation? Those who will be retiring in 2-3 years can afford to train less experienced engineers, but I believe that those with 20 years to run are much less likely to share what they've learned. This is especially true in companies with a history of “hire and fire.”
Special thanks to all of our readers who responded to this survey. We appreciate your input.
Share on:
Suggested Items
Offshore Sourcing in the Global Supply Chain
11/20/2024 | Brittany Martin, I-Connect007Bob Duke, president of the Global Sourcing Division at American Standard Circuits, discusses the challenges and benefits of navigating the global supply chain, including the value of strong supplier relationships, rigorous quality control, and strategic sourcing from regions including China, Vietnam, and India.
Understanding Cleaning Challenges for Automated Solder Paste Dispensing
09/18/2024 | Debbie Carboni, KYZENIn today’s rapidly evolving electronics manufacturing landscape, staying abreast of innovative technologies is crucial. As solder paste and substrate materials continually evolve and become more complex, optimizing production methods with the latest technology ensures performance and quality while reducing operational costs.
Moving from Surviving to Thriving
08/19/2024 | Mark Wolfe, IPCA few months ago, I shared some thoughts regarding the implications of the survival mode that most of us have lived in, at least for the past several years, within the electronics supply chain. In this article, I would like to share some additional thoughts about how companies can move away from merely surviving and work toward thriving across their supply chain. At a high level, here is what I believe the foundation of thriving looks like.
Market Spotlight on India
07/31/2024 | Marcy LaRont, PCB007 MagazineIndia has long fascinated me. Aside from the fact that I love the cuisine, I have been fortunate to have some close Indian friends who were very generous in sharing their culture, celebrations, and homes. Growing up in the Bay Area (Silicon Valley), my exposure to talented Indian engineers started in the 1990s.
Sustainability and Workforce Topics Dominate Day 2 of SEMICON West
07/16/2024 | Marcy LaRont, PCB007 MagazineSustainability and the workforce were prolific themes for the second day of SEMICON West on July 10 in San Francisco. Sustainability kicked off with keynote speaker Al Gore, the former U.S. vice president and arguably America’s most passionate environmental advocate for nearly 50 years. He once again outlined the serious environmental issues and timelines we are facing and emphasized the importance of the industry’s commitment to sustainability initiatives.