Collaboration Station
July 3, 2024 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamEstimated reading time: 2 minutes
As a PCB designer working for an EMS provider, Kelly Dack has seen his share of boards fail because they were designed in a vacuum; the designer simply threw the design “over the wall” and hoped for the best.
In this interview, Kelly discusses the need for collaboration between all the stakeholders involved in designing and manufacturing the PCB. As Kelly points out, IPC’s CID curriculum provides a great framework for setting up a collaboration culture in your company, and standards help enable this kind of environment.
Andy Shaughnessy: Kelly, we’re discussing collaboration between designers as well as between designers and their partners downstream. How does a company set up a collaboration culture?
Kelly Dack: You could say that great things happen when project stakeholders get together. Everybody can represent their own part of the project and come together. I teach the Certified Interconnect Designer (CID) class, and the CID principles teach us that at the start of a project, you've got to bring everybody together and put values on everything: test, mechanical, components, fit, performance, and all the other design forces. They all have to come together, and the project manager has to put weight on each of those things.
Shaughnessy: So, the CID provides a guideline for setting up a collaborative environment?
Dack: Absolutely. CID has a graphic that really hits the nail on the head. It is a picture of a table, with chairs around the table representing each stakeholder: testability guys, test engineer, mechanical engineer, PCB designer, electrical engineer, manufacturing engineer, and supplier management, who have to go buy all these parts and source the parts. This is the foundation of what needs to happen. The IPC CID program preaches that it takes a village, so to speak—a team of all the stakeholders—to buy in to make the product successful down the road. That’s basically the start of any conversation on collaboration.
Ideally, the project manager is the one who will pull all the stakeholders together, including the designer and engineer, so they can hear from each other. For instance, does this board need to be 100% testable? For one recent board, we went through several prototype development layout cycles just to get the circuit performance dialed in. Tragically, we found out after the layout was complete and functioning that it had to be 100% testable because the customer was going to pay for a test fixture. Design for testability (DFT) must be implemented at the start of design, or there will be no room to add the test points.
The worst time to implement DFT is after a board design is locked up and performing well. So, to prevent this from ever happening again, what did we do? We created an internal standard that said all boards shall be 100% testable. That’s good, but the problem is that this takes a lot more time and rules checking because we have introduced test points that could affect performance.
To read the entire interview, which originally published in the June 2024 Design007 Magazine, click here.
Suggested Items
Understanding PCB Board Fabrication for Engineers
06/07/2024 | IPCThis comprehensive webinar, which will be held on Jun 19, 2024 | 1:00 - 2:00pm EDT, provides insights into the process, making it a valuable resource for Electrical Engineers, PCB Layout Professionals, Supply Chain personnel, and anyone interested in PCB Board Fabrication.
Spring 2024 Santa Clara County Flexfactor Finals Held at Nextflex
05/20/2024 | NextFlexNextFlex hosts this semester’s FlexFactor. Four teams of high school students competed by pitching their inventive products to a panel of esteemed judges composed of Robert de Neve, General Partner & Chief Strategist General Partner & Chief Strategist at NextPhase Ventures; Christine Holly Ngo, VP of Operations and Business Development at Silicon Valley Elite Manufacturing, Inc; and Jackson Rambough, FHE Design and Process Engineer at NextFlex.
AT&S Adjusts Forecast, Not Considering a Capital Increase, Will Obtain Binding Offers for the Sale of Ansan
05/14/2024 | AT&SAT&S adjusts forecast for the financial year 2026/27, is currently not considering a capital increase, intends to obtain binding offers for the sale of the plant in Ansan, Korea, and proposes not to distribute a dividend for the financial year 2023/24.
The Chemical Connection: The High Cost of Etcher Non-maintenance
12/28/2023 | Don Ball -- Column: The Chemical ConnectionWe all understand that day-to-day maintenance and long-term preventive maintenance of etching equipment is a good thing. However, the pressing need to get product out the door in the face of tough production schedules can sometimes cause us to delay necessary maintenance for long periods of time. In some cases, we become fixated on short-term production and forget about long-term stability.
Sigma Mecer: Turning Copper ‘Green’
10/05/2023 | Nolan Johnson, PCB007 MagazineAndreas Littorin is CEO at Sigma Engineering AB. The company has been manufacturing equipment for the PCB industry for 45 years, mainly a mature product for copper recycling of alkaline and acidic etchants in the PCB manufacturing process.