-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- design007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssuePower Integrity
Current power demands are increasing, especially with AI, 5G, and EV chips. This month, our experts share “watt’s up” with power integrity, from planning and layout through measurement and manufacturing.
Signal Integrity
If you don’t have signal integrity problems now, you will eventually. This month, our expert contributors share a variety of SI techniques that can help designers avoid ground bounce, crosstalk, parasitic issues, and much more.
Proper Floor Planning
Floor planning decisions can make or break performance, manufacturability, and timelines. This month’s contributors weigh in with their best practices for proper floor planning and specific strategies to get it right.
- Articles
- Columns
- Links
- Media kit
||| MENU - design007 Magazine
Todd Westerhoff on the Value of Solid Design Skills
January 21, 2020 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 MagazineEstimated reading time: 5 minutes
I recently caught up with Todd Westerhoff, product marketing manager for Mentor’s HyperLynx signal integrity (SI) tools. Todd discusses some of the challenges that he and his customers are facing and why good design skills have more influence on a PCB than any software tool.
Andy Shaughnessy: Hi, Todd. For those who may not be familiar with you, give us a quick background about yourself and your time in PCB design and EDA industries.
Todd Westerhoff: I’ve been working with system simulation tools for the past 40 years. I started with digital logic/timing/fault simulation at GenRad and HHB Systems, added circuit simulation at FutureNet, VHDL at Racal-Redac, RF/ microwave analysis at Compact Software, and then got into high-speed design while consulting through ViewLogic. I’ve spent the past 23 years in SI, working for Cadence, Cisco, SiSoft, and Mentor, A Siemens Business in both design engineering and EDA marketing roles. I consider myself fortunate to have been both a user and provider of EDA tools; I think my experiences as a designer help me make better decisions with the capabilities we’re developing today.
Shaughnessy: What do you see as the biggest challenge right now for PCB designers and design engineers?
Westerhoff: SI has been one of those things that people have typically “left to the experts.” When I worked at Cisco, we had centralized SI groups supporting multiple design teams. The design team looked to the SI expert to determine what the routing rules should be and validate the design once routing was available. That worked when the number of critical interfaces in designs was small, but that’s no longer the case. Just about every signal on every design now qualifies as “high-speed” if you compare the driver’s edge rate to the net’s electrical length.
But what’s a designer supposed to do? There aren’t nearly enough SI experts to go around, and the ones we do have are focused on the cutting edge stuff. Designers still need to make tradeoffs on high-interfaces when they can’t route “according to pre-defined rules,” but they don’t necessarily have access to the analysis support they need. That suggests that basic design simulation needs to be part of the designer’s desktop toolkit, although progress has been slow in that area. I would maintain that the same is true for other disciplines. It’s not just SI—you can add power integrity (PI), EMI/EMC, thermal, and others to that mix. A designer needs to know a lot about many different disciplines to be successful today.
Shaughnessy: What do you see as the biggest challenge right now for PCB designers and design engineers?
Westerhoff: SI has been one of those things that people have typically “left to the experts.” When I worked at Cisco, we had centralized SI groups supporting multiple design teams. The design team looked to the SI expert to determine what the routing rules should be and validate the design once routing was available. That worked when the number of critical inter-faces in designs was small, but that’s no longer the case. Just about every signal on every de-sign now qualifies as “high-speed” if you com-pare the driver’s edge rate to the net’s electrical length.
But what’s a designer supposed to do? There aren’t nearly enough SI experts to go around, and the ones we do have are focused on the cutting edge stuff. Designers still need to make tradeoffs on high-interfaces when they can’t route “according to pre-defined rules,” but they don’t necessarily have access to the analysis support they need. That suggests that basic design simulation needs to be part of the designer’s desktop toolkit, al-though progress has been slow in that area. I would maintain that the same is true for other disciplines. It’s not just SI—you can add power integrity (PI), EMI/EMC, thermal, and others to that mix. A designer needs to know a lot about many different disciplines to be successful today.
In most companies, the “design review” is how designers get feedback on their work by having it reviewed by peers and experts. Design reviews take significant time and effort, but they’re quicker and less resource-intensive than full-scale modeling and simulation. But there’s still a rub; running a design review requires check-pointing the design, sending something out for review, and waiting for people (who are already busy with other tasks) to review the material, and then pulling all that feedback together. That represents a consider-able delay in a project schedule that’s already packed.
Ideally, we’d combine the ability to perform first-order analysis on the engineer’s desktop, allowing the evaluation of design tradeoffs with automated multi-domain design reviews to provide feedback in near real-time. That way, designers could minimize the risk and delays they experience with the ways we do things today. I think the biggest challenge designers face today is simply trying to learn everything they need to know and analyze to make sure their designs work as intended. We’d like to help ease that burden a bit.
Shaughnessy: I know you like to take devices apart around the house. Have you had any more epiphanies, like the one you shared with me at DesignCon about the new Ethernet switch and the need for designers to know how to do a “cost-reduced” design?
Westerhoff: As it turns out, I’ve been both taking things apart and putting things together. As far as taking things apart, I had an LED bulb fail in my home office and decided to take a look inside (Figure 1). It’s official: We’ve reached the point where we commonly have integrated circuits inside light bulbs! Thankfully, this particular bulb is a commodity item that doesn’t take up an IP address on my wireless network, although I’m sure that some bulbs do.
To read this entire interview, which appeared in the November 2019 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.
Testimonial
"The I-Connect007 team is outstanding—kind, responsive, and a true marketing partner. Their design team created fresh, eye-catching ads, and their editorial support polished our content to let our brand shine. Thank you all! "
Sweeney Ng - CEE PCBSuggested Items
Zuken Announces ZIW Americas 2026 in Dallas
10/21/2025 | ZukenZuken USA, Inc., a global leader in electrical and electronic design automation, announced Zuken Innovation World (ZIW) Americas 2026, the company’s premier global conference dedicated to advancing the future of electrical and electronic product design. ZIW 2026 will be held June 9-11 in Dallas, Texas.
Keysight Completes Acquisition of Synopsys’ Optical Solutions Group and Ansys’ PowerArtist
10/17/2025 | Keysight Technologies, Inc.Keysight Technologies, Inc., announced the completion of its acquisitions of the Optical Solutions Group from Synopsys, Inc., and PowerArtist from Ansys, Inc.
RT-Labs Joins STMicroelectronics Partner Program to Accelerate Industrial Communication
10/16/2025 | RT-LabsRT-Labs, a leading provider of real-time software solutions for industrial automation, announces that it has joined the STMicroelectronics Partner Program to integrate its Ethernet-based industrial communication stacks into ST’s development environments and microcontroller platforms.
ASC Sunstone Circuits Adds New Options to OneQuote While Maintaining Real-Time Pricing on Core PCB Features
10/16/2025 | ASC Sunstone CircuitsASC Sunstone Circuits, a leading U.S. PCB manufacturer, today announced a significant expansion of its OneQuote online quoting tool, giving design engineers more control over complex PCB configurations — making it easier for the quote team to quickly clarify and verify specifications, reducing delays from manual quote reviews.
Analog Devices Launches ADI Power Studio™ and New Web-Based Tools
10/14/2025 | Analog Devices, Inc.Analog Devices, Inc., a global semiconductor leader, announced the launch of ADI Power Studio, a comprehensive family of products that offers advanced modeling, component recommendations and efficiency analysis with simulation. In addition, ADI is introducing early versions of two new web-based tools with a modernized user experience under the Power Studio umbrella: