-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- design007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueMechatronics
Our expert contributors discuss the advent of mechatronics in PCB design, the challenges and opportunities this creates for circuit board designers, and the benefits—to the employee and the company—of becoming a mechatronics engineer.
Creating a Culture of Collaboration
PCB designers could learn quite a bit from NASA and the private companies that develop spacecraft: Every one of these vehicles is a testament to the value of collaboration among disparate stakeholders. Without a collaborative culture, the rocket might never get off the ground.
Breaking High-speed Material Constraints
Do you need specialty materials for your high-speed designs? Maybe not. Improvements in resins mean designers of high-speed boards can sometimes use traditional laminate systems. Learn more in this issue.
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Events
||| MENU - design007 Magazine
A Design Economics Horror Story
May 7, 2020 | Rick Hartley, RHartley EnterprisesEstimated reading time: 3 minutes
Editor’s note: During a recent conversation with Rick Hartley, he shared one of his favorite PCB design horror stories. This is a cautionary tale about what can happen when design teams place too much faith in app notes and do not follow cost-aware design techniques. Enjoy!
When I first went to work at a company in 2003, I was asked to look at a circuit board that was not working properly; the few they did get to work had major EMI problems. I discovered they had placed the parts badly so that routing the memory lines to be even close to a similar length was going to be nearly impossible.
The engineer who did the schematic looked at the app note for the particular memory that was used with this processor, which stated, “Route all the memory lines within the same length of one another at ±50 mils.” The engineer thought, “50 is good, and 25 is even better,” so he put a note on this schematic that the memory lines should all be the same length at ±25 mils. What’s really interesting is that engineers often don’t understand that inner and outer layers propagate at different rates. If you make all the lines the same length, they don’t have the same propagation time, and they don’t match anyway.
Then, they farmed out the layout. And the people who did the layout—because of the poor positioning of components—couldn’t get all the lines routed anywhere close to the same length without a ton of tromboning or serpentining of the memory lines. They ended up with 14 routing layers, and the only way they could get it to the thickness required was to make it an 18-layer board. They had an 18-layer board with only four plane layers and 14 routing layers. Anybody who knows anything about design is already thinking, “How could this possibly work?”
It all happened because of this overabundance of length-matching. To make matters worse, they had to have 65 ohms impedance on some of the lines because there was a PCI bus on the board. In order to get the dielectric constant—with these very thin dielectrics— low enough to hit the target impedance, they had to go to Rogers 4000 series material (at 6 to 8 times the cost of FR-4). The bare boards were seven by nine inches, and they were going to cost an estimated $235 each in quantities of 1,000 at a time. Again, most of the boards didn’t work, and the few that did work failed EMI testing and were expensive.
I looked at the board and realized what the problem was. I asked the engineer why he put that note on the schematic. And he said, “It was in the app note. I figured they knew what they were talking about.” I asked, “Did you do a timing analysis?” He replied, “You know what management around here is like. We never have time for things like that.” I said, “Do you have time now to do a timing analysis?”
The engineer came back to me a day later and said, “By my calculation, we have about ±200–300 picoseconds of available skew.” I asked him, “Do you know how much that is in terms of length? It’s somewhere between two and three inches. Let’s even call it an inch. That means you could have made all these memory lines the same length ± 1inch, and they would have all worked.”
He exclaimed, “Bull. I don’t believe it.” I said, “Well, we are going to prove it to you!” We stripped away the routes, repositioned the components to make things route properly, routed the board with no line matching at all, and checked them when we were done, and they were all within an inch of the same length. We did no serpentining at all. We made a 10-layer board out of it instead of an 18-layer board with six routing layers and four plane layers.
It worked perfectly. It passed EMI testing, and the price dropped to $34 per board from $235 per board. That’s what happens when people blindly follow app notes.
Close-up of the original 18-layer board showing an abundance of tromboning.
This article originally appeared in the April 2020 issue of Design007 Magazine.
Suggested Items
Looking For That Perfect Job? Check Out jobCONNECT007
07/25/2024 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamThere are a lot of open positions in this industry today. But where do you begin to look? We have the answer: jobCONNECT007, your guide to career opportunities in the electronic industry. In jobCONNECT007, you’ll find job openings that span the entire circuit board supply chain. Whether you’re involved in design, fabrication, assembly, test, or material development or distribution, this handy resource can help you get on your way to a new gig.
Strip Etch Strip: Episode 9 of On the Line With... Designing for Reality Podcast Now Available
07/25/2024 | I-Connect007Don't miss the latest episode of "On the Line With... Designing for Reality," where we walk through the PCB manufacturing process. At this stage, we have a panel made up of all the internal layers laminated together, through-holes drilled, and the outer layer copper features covered with a protective layer of tin.
Ventec Giga Solutions & Hi-Print Team up to Launch World's First 3-Color Inkjet Printing Solution
07/24/2024 | Ventec International GroupVentec Giga Solutions, Ventec’s value-added PCB equipment division, and leading inkjet printer manufacturer Hi-Print have teamed up to launch the industry’s most cutting-edge inkjet printer for solder mask technology.
Ian Walsh Appointed as Sondrel’s Regional VP for America
07/23/2024 | SondrellSondrel, a leading provider of ultra-complex, custom chips for leading global technology brands, has appointed Ian Walsh as its Regional VP for America, with the responsibility of growing Sondrel’s US semiconductor business from its new Silicon Valley offices in Santa Clara, CA.
LG Accelerates Smart Factory Solutions Business Integrating AI with 66-year Manufacturing Expertise
07/23/2024 | LGLG Electronics is advancing its smart factory solutions business by integrating artificial intelligence (AI) and digital transformation (DX) with its extensive 66-year history of manufacturing and production expertise.